水文变异分析的外文论文
Y.Gaoetal./JournalofHydrology374(2009)136–147137
TheIHAcontains33hydrologicparametersthatcharacterizetheintra-andinter-annualvariationin ows,accordingtothefollow-ing vecharacteristicsof owregimes:magnitudeofmonthlystream ows,magnitudeanddurationofannualextreme ows,timingofannualextreme ows,frequencyanddurationofhighandlowpulses,rateandfrequencyof owchanges(MathewsandRichter,2007).Similartomostotherproposedindicators,manyIHAparametersareintercorrelated(OldenandPoff,2003),promotingalevelofnumericalredundancyandpotentiallycom-plicatingenvironmental owassessments(Arthingtonetal.2006).Developingasmallnumberofstatisticsthatcapturekeycompo-nentsofecologicallyrelevant owvariationwill:(1)contributetoageneralapproachforcharacterizing owalteration,(2)minimizestatisticalredundancyandcomputationaleffortinfutureanalyses,and(3)facilitateourabilitytoobtainPareto-optimalsolutionsforenvironmental owschemes(seeShiauandWu,2006,2007;SuenandEheart,2006).Pareto-optimalsolutionsforenvironmental owschemesinvolveadeterminationofthetradeoffsbetweenhumanwatersupplyandecological owobjectives.Whilethereareawiderangeofpossiblewatersupplyobjectives,rangingfromsuchcon-ceptsasvulnerability,resilienceandreliability,towaterquality,securityandcost,manystudiessimplyfocusonasingleobjectivesuchasreliability.Bycomparison,thereisnoacceptedsingleorevensmallsetofenvironmentalorinstream owobjectives.Thusoneofthebiggestcurrentchallengesassociatedwithbalancinghu-manandecological owneedsinvolvesadeterminationofasmallsetofrepresentativeindicatorswhichre ectalterationtoecologi-cal owregimes.Thisisthesubjectofourpaper.
Previousstudieshavesoughttoexploreredundancyamonghydrologicmetrics.Forexample,OldenandPoff(2003)usedprin-cipalcomponentanalysis(PCA)toevaluatepatternsofstatisticalvariationamong171publishedhydrologicindicatorsandcon-cludedthatthe33IHAscapturethemajorityofthevariation,andthuscanbeusedtorepresentthemajoraspectsofthe owre-gime.Similarly,Yangetal.(2008)identi edasmallsubsetofhydrologicindicatorsthatwerethemostrepresentativeofecolog-ical owregimes.Theyevaluatedthreeapproaches(geneticpro-gramming,principalcomponentanalysisandautecologymatrix)resultingtheselectionofsixIHAparameters(Dateofminimum,RiseRate,Numberofreversals,3-daymaximum,7-dayminimumandMay ow)asthemostecologicallyrelevanthydrologicindica-tors(ERHIs).
Theprimarygoalofourstudyistodetermine,amongalargesuiteofindicatorsofhydrologicalteration,thecombinationofsta-tisticsthatbestprovideanoverallmeasureofhydrologicalter-ation.Forthispurpose,weconsiderthesuiteofIHAstatistics,aswellasafewgeneralizedindicatorsoftheecological owregimestermedtheDundeeHydrologicalRegimeAlterationMethod(DHRAM)(Blacketal.,2005)andtherecentlyintroducedindicestermedecosurplusandecode cit(Vogeletal.,2007).
MethodologyData
TheIHAisasuiteofstatisticsdevelopedbyTheUSNatureCon-servancy(doc.guandang.net)toassessthedegreeofhydro-logicalterationcausedbyhumanactivities.Itconsistsof67parameters,whicharesubdividedintotwogroups-33IHAparam-etersand34EFC(EnvironmentalFlowComponent)parameters.Thesehydrologicparametersweredevelopedbasedontheireco-logicalrelevanceandtheirabilitytore ecthuman-inducedchangesin owregimesacrossabroadrangeofin uencesinclud-ingdamoperations,waterdiversions,ground-waterpumping,andlandscapemodi cation(MathewsandRichter,2007).TheIHA
parameters,listedinTable1,arethesubjectofthisstudy(seeIHAUser’sManual(TheNatureConservancy,2006)forde nitionoftheparameters).Acommonapproachtoassessinghydrologicalterationinvolvesacomparisonof owregimesbetweenpres-ent-day(impacted)andpast(unimpacted)timeperiods.FollowingRichteretal.(1996),weconsideredthepercentagechangeinthemedianvaluesoftheIHAparametersbetweenunregulated(pre-dam)andregulated(post-dam) owregimesfortwosetsofstream owdata,asimulatedsetandanempiricalset.Theparam-eter‘‘numberofzero- owdays”wasexcludedfromtheanalysis,becausetherewasnozero- owdayformostofthegagesduringtheunregulatedperiodsinourstudy;thusthepercentageofchangecouldnotbecomputedbecausethedenominatorwaszero.ThesimulateddataserieswasthesameseriesintroducedbyVogeletal.(2007)forthepurposeofevaluatingawiderangeofreservoirreleasepoliciescorrespondingtoawiderangeofhypo-theticalreservoirsystemsallsimulatedforasingleriver.Theunregulatedstream owdatainthesimulateddatasetcomefromtheUSGSgage01333000(GreenRiveratWilliamstown,MA;drain-agearea=110km2),andtheregulatedstream ow,forthesimu-lateddataset,aregeneratedfromthewatermanagementsoftware,WaterEvaluationAndPlanningSystem(WEAP),devel-opedbytheStockholmEnvironmentInstitute(Yatesetal.,2005).Stream owregulationinthiscaserefersto12releaserulesoperat-ingoneightimaginaryreservoirswithstorageratios(ratioofstor-agecapacityStomeanannualin owl)intherangeof0.01–3(seeVogeletal.,2007forfurtherdetails).Hence,thenumberofobser-vationsofthesimulatedstream owseriesis12Â8=96.Sincethisdatasetisonlybasedonasinglerivergage,wefeltitwasimpor-tanttoexpandourexperimentbyusinganotherdataset,describedbelow,whichemploysactualstream owdatasubjecttoavarietyof owalterationschemesfrommanyriversanddams.
Aseconddataset,termedtheempiricaldataset,isasetofstream owdatafrom189USGSstream owgagesinthird-throughseventh-orderriversdistributedacrossthecontinentalUS.Flowgageswerelocated0.1–74kmdownstreamofdams(mean=17km).Thefollowingcriteriawereusedtoensurethattherecordofeachgagere ectedthein uenceofasingledam:(1)nopre-existingupstreammainstemdam,(2)atleast15yearsofdailystream owdatabothbeforeandafterthedamcompletiondate,(3)nomorethantwotributaryinputsbetweentheupstreamdamandthegage,and(4)nodamsontributarieswithanesti-mateddrainagearealargerthanthemainstemriverofthecandi-datedam(seePoffetal.,2007formoredetails).Fig.1showsthelocationsofthe189dams.Noinformationisavailableregardingthetypeofreservoirreleaserulesemployedbythesedams.MulticollinearityofIHAstatistics
Figs.2and3illustrateboxplotsofthecorrelationcoef cientsbetweeneachIHAstatisticandtheremaining31IHAstatistics
Table1
Thirty-threeindicatorsofhydrologicalteration.October owSeptember owNumberofzero- owdaysaNovember ow1-dayminimumBase owindexDecember ow3-dayminimumDateofminimumJanuary ow7-dayminimumDateofmaximumFebruary ow30-dayminimumLowpulsecountMarch ow90-dayminimumLowpulsedurationApril ow1-daymaximumHighpulsecountMay ow3-daymaximumHighpulsedurationJune ow7-daymaximumRiserateJuly ow30-daymaximumFallrate
August ow
90-daymaximum
Numberofreversals
a
Thisparameterisexcludedfromthestudy.
This method, referred to as the ‘Indicators of Hydrologic Alteration’, is...development annual values falling within the RVA target range equals the ...
表 2 长江干流关键点水文变化指数 (IHA 统计表 ) Table 2 Indicators of Hydrologic Alteration(IHA in Critical Sections of the Yangtze River ) 水文变 化...
and determines the range of environmental flow through calculation of 32 indicators of hydrologic alteration ( IHA) . Combining several common methods of ...
3 流量指标计算及选择 IHA 全称 Indicators of Hydrologic Alteration, 它是用来...Burges S J. Effects of urban development in the Puget Lowland, Washington,...
17 18 3 评价人类活动对流量制度(Flow Regime) 影响程度的一个方法: 水文变化指标(Indicators of Hydrologic Alteration, IHA)法 水文变化指标(Indicators IHA)法 ...
indicators of hydrologic alteration is a statistical tool that offers a view...development of a stage-discharge relation for a riffle and determination of ...
5 Degrees of hydrologic alteration of 32 IHAs in Jianli,Chenglingji and 656...indicators of hydrological characteristics The study is financially supported by...
3.1.2 指数选取选用最能反映河流生态系统生物多样性和发挥河流自然生态功能为目标的 水文变化指数(IHA, Indicators of Hydrologic Alteration),通过 RVA(Range ...
reference value in the actual water conservancy construction and development. ...Indicators of Hydrologic Alteration, Range of Variability Approach, the Hydrologic...
Brian D Richter 等于1997 年提出IHA [3] [1] [2] ( Indicators of Hydrologic Alteration) 法 用于评价人类活动对河流径流过程的影响,分析河流在人类活动干扰...
(Indicators of Hydrologic Alteration , IHA) ,澳 大利亚 Growns 等 提出的 7 类 91 个指标,张洪波等 提出了包含 7 类 50 个生态水文指标的黄河生态水〔8...
热门文档