文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 工程科技 > 电力/水利 > Development of representative indicators of hydrologic alteration
侵权投诉

Development of representative indicators of hydrologic alteration

水文变异分析的外文论文

Y.Gaoetal./JournalofHydrology374(2009)136–147137

TheIHAcontains33hydrologicparametersthatcharacterizetheintra-andinter-annualvariationin ows,accordingtothefollow-ing vecharacteristicsof owregimes:magnitudeofmonthlystream ows,magnitudeanddurationofannualextreme ows,timingofannualextreme ows,frequencyanddurationofhighandlowpulses,rateandfrequencyof owchanges(MathewsandRichter,2007).Similartomostotherproposedindicators,manyIHAparametersareintercorrelated(OldenandPoff,2003),promotingalevelofnumericalredundancyandpotentiallycom-plicatingenvironmental owassessments(Arthingtonetal.2006).Developingasmallnumberofstatisticsthatcapturekeycompo-nentsofecologicallyrelevant owvariationwill:(1)contributetoageneralapproachforcharacterizing owalteration,(2)minimizestatisticalredundancyandcomputationaleffortinfutureanalyses,and(3)facilitateourabilitytoobtainPareto-optimalsolutionsforenvironmental owschemes(seeShiauandWu,2006,2007;SuenandEheart,2006).Pareto-optimalsolutionsforenvironmental owschemesinvolveadeterminationofthetradeoffsbetweenhumanwatersupplyandecological owobjectives.Whilethereareawiderangeofpossiblewatersupplyobjectives,rangingfromsuchcon-ceptsasvulnerability,resilienceandreliability,towaterquality,securityandcost,manystudiessimplyfocusonasingleobjectivesuchasreliability.Bycomparison,thereisnoacceptedsingleorevensmallsetofenvironmentalorinstream owobjectives.Thusoneofthebiggestcurrentchallengesassociatedwithbalancinghu-manandecological owneedsinvolvesadeterminationofasmallsetofrepresentativeindicatorswhichre ectalterationtoecologi-cal owregimes.Thisisthesubjectofourpaper.

Previousstudieshavesoughttoexploreredundancyamonghydrologicmetrics.Forexample,OldenandPoff(2003)usedprin-cipalcomponentanalysis(PCA)toevaluatepatternsofstatisticalvariationamong171publishedhydrologicindicatorsandcon-cludedthatthe33IHAscapturethemajorityofthevariation,andthuscanbeusedtorepresentthemajoraspectsofthe owre-gime.Similarly,Yangetal.(2008)identi edasmallsubsetofhydrologicindicatorsthatwerethemostrepresentativeofecolog-ical owregimes.Theyevaluatedthreeapproaches(geneticpro-gramming,principalcomponentanalysisandautecologymatrix)resultingtheselectionofsixIHAparameters(Dateofminimum,RiseRate,Numberofreversals,3-daymaximum,7-dayminimumandMay ow)asthemostecologicallyrelevanthydrologicindica-tors(ERHIs).

Theprimarygoalofourstudyistodetermine,amongalargesuiteofindicatorsofhydrologicalteration,thecombinationofsta-tisticsthatbestprovideanoverallmeasureofhydrologicalter-ation.Forthispurpose,weconsiderthesuiteofIHAstatistics,aswellasafewgeneralizedindicatorsoftheecological owregimestermedtheDundeeHydrologicalRegimeAlterationMethod(DHRAM)(Blacketal.,2005)andtherecentlyintroducedindicestermedecosurplusandecode cit(Vogeletal.,2007).

MethodologyData

TheIHAisasuiteofstatisticsdevelopedbyTheUSNatureCon-servancy(doc.guandang.net)toassessthedegreeofhydro-logicalterationcausedbyhumanactivities.Itconsistsof67parameters,whicharesubdividedintotwogroups-33IHAparam-etersand34EFC(EnvironmentalFlowComponent)parameters.Thesehydrologicparametersweredevelopedbasedontheireco-logicalrelevanceandtheirabilitytore ecthuman-inducedchangesin owregimesacrossabroadrangeofin uencesinclud-ingdamoperations,waterdiversions,ground-waterpumping,andlandscapemodi cation(MathewsandRichter,2007).TheIHA

parameters,listedinTable1,arethesubjectofthisstudy(seeIHAUser’sManual(TheNatureConservancy,2006)forde nitionoftheparameters).Acommonapproachtoassessinghydrologicalterationinvolvesacomparisonof owregimesbetweenpres-ent-day(impacted)andpast(unimpacted)timeperiods.FollowingRichteretal.(1996),weconsideredthepercentagechangeinthemedianvaluesoftheIHAparametersbetweenunregulated(pre-dam)andregulated(post-dam) owregimesfortwosetsofstream owdata,asimulatedsetandanempiricalset.Theparam-eter‘‘numberofzero- owdays”wasexcludedfromtheanalysis,becausetherewasnozero- owdayformostofthegagesduringtheunregulatedperiodsinourstudy;thusthepercentageofchangecouldnotbecomputedbecausethedenominatorwaszero.ThesimulateddataserieswasthesameseriesintroducedbyVogeletal.(2007)forthepurposeofevaluatingawiderangeofreservoirreleasepoliciescorrespondingtoawiderangeofhypo-theticalreservoirsystemsallsimulatedforasingleriver.Theunregulatedstream owdatainthesimulateddatasetcomefromtheUSGSgage01333000(GreenRiveratWilliamstown,MA;drain-agearea=110km2),andtheregulatedstream ow,forthesimu-lateddataset,aregeneratedfromthewatermanagementsoftware,WaterEvaluationAndPlanningSystem(WEAP),devel-opedbytheStockholmEnvironmentInstitute(Yatesetal.,2005).Stream owregulationinthiscaserefersto12releaserulesoperat-ingoneightimaginaryreservoirswithstorageratios(ratioofstor-agecapacityStomeanannualin owl)intherangeof0.01–3(seeVogeletal.,2007forfurtherdetails).Hence,thenumberofobser-vationsofthesimulatedstream owseriesis12Â8=96.Sincethisdatasetisonlybasedonasinglerivergage,wefeltitwasimpor-tanttoexpandourexperimentbyusinganotherdataset,describedbelow,whichemploysactualstream owdatasubjecttoavarietyof owalterationschemesfrommanyriversanddams.

Aseconddataset,termedtheempiricaldataset,isasetofstream owdatafrom189USGSstream owgagesinthird-throughseventh-orderriversdistributedacrossthecontinentalUS.Flowgageswerelocated0.1–74kmdownstreamofdams(mean=17km).Thefollowingcriteriawereusedtoensurethattherecordofeachgagere ectedthein uenceofasingledam:(1)nopre-existingupstreammainstemdam,(2)atleast15yearsofdailystream owdatabothbeforeandafterthedamcompletiondate,(3)nomorethantwotributaryinputsbetweentheupstreamdamandthegage,and(4)nodamsontributarieswithanesti-mateddrainagearealargerthanthemainstemriverofthecandi-datedam(seePoffetal.,2007formoredetails).Fig.1showsthelocationsofthe189dams.Noinformationisavailableregardingthetypeofreservoirreleaserulesemployedbythesedams.MulticollinearityofIHAstatistics

Figs.2and3illustrateboxplotsofthecorrelationcoef cientsbetweeneachIHAstatisticandtheremaining31IHAstatistics

Table1

Thirty-threeindicatorsofhydrologicalteration.October owSeptember owNumberofzero- owdaysaNovember ow1-dayminimumBase owindexDecember ow3-dayminimumDateofminimumJanuary ow7-dayminimumDateofmaximumFebruary ow30-dayminimumLowpulsecountMarch ow90-dayminimumLowpulsedurationApril ow1-daymaximumHighpulsecountMay ow3-daymaximumHighpulsedurationJune ow7-daymaximumRiserateJuly ow30-daymaximumFallrate

August ow

90-daymaximum

Numberofreversals

a

Thisparameterisexcludedfromthestudy.

上一页第2页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email