of the Delhi Government were focused on protecting New Delhi’s citizens rather than improving the lives of the poorest city dwellers. Through a closely worked discussion of urban infrastructural improvements and slum clearance measures in the 1920s and 1930s, Legg shows that schemes designed to improve Old Delhi were hamstrung by shortages of funds, bureaucratic red tape, and an under-lying ideology that privileged a notion of ‘containing the poor’. Whereas liberal govern-ments in Europe tended to invest in broad-based health initiatives in the rst half of the twentieth century, the Delhi government tended to baulk at such welfare measures, and colonialists repeatedly pitted a healthy, ordered and beautiful New Delhi against a vision of Old Delhi: fetid, unruly and unmanageable.The conclusion nicely illustrates the achievements of the book: its basis in rich eld research, its clever and instructive use of Foucault, and its attention simultaneously to the machinations of urban governmentality and agency of city dwellers. Legg emphasizes the distributed nature of public critique, which only occasionally coheres into ‘resistance’.One of Legg’s particular strengths is to blend conceptual discussion with detailed empirical description. In Chapter Two, for example, he introduces us to the distinction that Foucault makes between ‘derived con-tradictions’ – localized assertions that play by the rules of dominant discourse – and ‘intrinsic contradictions’: more radical forms of dissent with the potential to transform discursive practice. Legg proceeds to put this conceptual schema to work, showing that public criticisms of Delhi government institutions moved beyond the derived con-tradictions of a bureaucracy that could not provide appropriate accommodation for state employees but also – at the intrinsic level – challenged the racial biases of Imperial housing policy.
Legg might have investigated in more detail the relationship between critiques of urban governmentality and Indian nationalism, but he does acknowledge this relative absence in
Book reviews 141
the book, and the conclusions offer a useful guide to further avenues for research. I also wondered at various points about the use of western Europe as a foil for the account of urban governmentality in India. In his attempt to identify a distinctive colonial regime of rule (for example, on p. 148), Legg possibly exaggerates the ‘liberal checks’ characteristic of policing in Europe in the early twentieth century.
But these are minor points in what is a beautifully crafted book on the historical geo-graphy of Delhi. The book’s original approach, conceptual rigour and clarity make it required reading for historical geographers of colonial power and a valuable resource for geographers and historians more broadly.
Craig Jeffrey
St John’s College, Oxford
DOI: 10.1177/0309132509340076
Nevins, J., photographs by Aizeki, M. 2008: Dying to live: a story of U.S. immigration in an age of global apartheid. San Francisco, CA: City Lights. 225 pp. $16.95 paper. ISBN: 978 0 87286 486 3.
Dying to live is a powerful examination of the messy politics and human consequences of US immigration policies. Joseph Nevins skillfully weaves the personal story of Julio César Gallegos, a migrant who died attempt-ing to cross the US-Mexico boundary, together with detailed historical research to explore the boundary’s ideological con-struction, the USA’s ‘race-class-nation hierarchy’, and the role of law in shaping Americans’ geographical imagination. Mizui Aizeki’s striking black and white photos of boundary scenes and Gallegos’ family scattered throughout the book punctuate Nevins’ arguments. Despite some overlap in arguments between this book and Nevins’ Operation Gatekeeper (2002), Dying to live is quite worth the attention of scholars for the
Mandela’s autobiography is a very fascinating ...It is the story of one of the truly greatest ...participants of the anti-apartheid struggle for 27...
The story of Lei Feng, an altruistic soldier in...s efforts to end apartheid in South Africa; ...create new heroes – both local and global ones...
热门文档