Welcome to the new HBR.org. Here’s what’s new. Here’s an FAQ.
ASSESSING PERFORMANCE
How to Play to Your Strengths
by Laura Morgan Roberts, Gretchen Spreitzer, Jane E. Dutton, Robert E. Quinn, Emily Heaphy, and Brianna Barker
FROM THE JANUARY 2005 ISSUEMost feedback accentuates the negative. During formal employee evaluations, discussions invariably focus on “opportunities for
improvement,” even if the overall evaluation is laudatory. Informally, the sting of criticism lasts longer than the balm of praise.
Multiple studies have shown that people pay keen attention to negative information. For example, when asked to recall important
emotional events, people remember four negative memories for every positive one. No wonder most executives give and receive performancereviews with all the enthusiasm of a child on the way to the dentist.
Traditional, corrective feedback has its place, of course; every organization must lter out failing employees and ensure that everyone performs atan expected level of competence. Unfortunately, feedback that ferrets out aws can lead otherwise talented managers to overinvest in shoring up orpapering over their perceived weaknesses, or forcing themselves onto an ill- tting template. Ironically, such a focus on problem areas prevents
companies from reaping the best performance from its people. After all, it’s a rare baseball player who is equally good at every position. Why shoulda natural third baseman labor to develop his skills as a right elder?
Why should a natural third baseman labor to develop his skills as a
right elder?The alternative, as the Gallup Organization researchers Marcus Buckingham, Donald Clifton, and others have suggested, is to foster excellence inthe third baseman by identifying and harnessing his unique strengths. It is a paradox of human psychology that while people remember criticism,they respond to praise. The former makes them defensive and therefore unlikely to change, while the latter produces con dence and the desire toperform better. Managers who build up their strengths can reach their highest potential. This positive approach does not pretend to ignore or denythe problems that traditional feedback mechanisms identify. Rather, it o ers a separate and unique feedback experience that counterbalancesnegative input. It allows managers to tap into strengths they may or may not be aware of and so contribute more to their organizations.
During the past few years, we have developed a powerful tool to help people understand and leverage their individual talents. Called the Re ectedBest Self (RBS) exercise, our method allows managers to develop a sense of their “personal best” in order to increase their future potential. The RBSexercise is but one example of new approaches springing from an area of research called positive organizational scholarship (POS). Just as
psychologists know that people respond better to praise than to criticism, organizational behavior scholars are nding that when companies focuson positive attributes such as resilience and trust, they can reap impressive bottom-line returns. (For more on this research, see the sidebar “ThePositive Organization.”) Thousands of executives, as well as tomorrow’s leaders enrolled in business schools around the world, have completed theRBS exercise.
The Positive OrganizationIn this article, we will walk you through the RBS exercise step-by-stepPositive organizational scholarship (POS) is an area of organizationaland describe the insights and results it can yield. Before we proceed,behavior research that focuses on the positive dynamics (such as strength,however, a few caveats are in order. First, understand that the tool is notresilience, vitality, trust, and so on) that lead to positive effects (like
improved productivity and performance) in individuals and organizations.designed to stroke your ego; its purpose is to assist you in developing aThe word “positive” refers to the discipline’s af rmative bias,plan for more e ective action. (Without such a plan, you’ll keep running“organizational” focuses on the processes and conditions that occur in
group contexts, and “scholarship” re ects the rigor, theory, scienti cin place.) Second, the lessons generated from the RBS exercise can elude
procedures, and precise de nition in which the approach is grounded.you if you don’t pay sincere attention to them. If you are too burdened by
time pressures and job demands, you may just le the information away
The premise of POS research is that by understanding the drivers of positiveand forget about it. To be e ective, the exercise requires commitment,behavior in the workplace, organizations can rise to new levels of
achievement. For example, research by Marcial Losada and Emily Heaphydiligence, and follow-through. It may even be helpful to have a coachat the University of Michigan suggests that when individuals or teams hearkeep you on task. Third, it’s important to conduct the RBS exercise at a ve positive comments to every negative one, they unleash a level of
positive energy that fuels higher levels of individual and group
performance. Kim Cameron, a POS researcher, has demonstrated how thisdi erent time of year than the traditional performance review so that
positive approach has helped the workers at Rocky Flats, a nuclear site innegative feedback from traditional mechanisms doesn’t interfere with theColorado, tackle dif cult and dangerous work in record time. Begun in 1995results of the exercise.
and estimated to take 70 years and $36 billion, the Rocky Flats cleanup
project is now slated for completion in ten years, with a price tag of less
than $7 billion. Kaiser-Hill, the company in charge of the cleanup, replacedUsed correctly, the RBS exercise can help you tap into unrecognized anda culture of denial with one that fostered employee exibility and
celebrated achievements. The result was that employees developed newunexplored areas of potential. Armed with a constructive, systematicprocedures that were fast, smart, and safe.process for gathering and analyzing data about your best self, you can
burnish your performance at work.
POS does not adopt one particular theory or framework but draws from the
full spectrum of organizational theories to explain and predict high
performance. To that end, a core part of the POS mission is to create cases,Step 1
tools, and assessments that can help organizations improve their
practices. The Re ected Best Self exercise is just one example of the kinds
of practice tools available from POS. (For more information about POS, see

Identify Respondents and Ask for Feedback
the University of Michigan’s Web site at doc.guandang.net.)The rst task in the exercise is to collect feedback from a variety of people
inside and outside work. By gathering input from a variety of sources—
family members, past and present colleagues, friends, teachers, and so on
—you can develop a much broader and richer understanding of yourself than you can from a standard performance evaluation.
As we describe the process of the Re ected Best Self exercise, we will highlight the experience of Robert Duggan (not his real name), whose self-discovery process is typical of the managers we’ve observed. Having retired from a successful career in the military at a fairly young age and earnedan MBA from a top business school, Robert accepted a midlevel management position at an IT services rm. Despite strong credentials and
leadership experience, Robert remained stuck in the same position year after year. His performance evaluations were generally good but not strongenough to put him on the high-potential track. Disengaged, frustrated, and disheartened, Robert grew increasingly stressed and disillusioned withhis company. His workday felt more and more like an episode of Survivor.
Seeking to improve his performance, Robert enrolled in an executive education program and took the RBS exercise. As part of the exercise, Robertgathered feedback from 11 individuals from his past and present who knew him well. He selected a diverse but balanced group—his wife and twoother family members, two friends from his MBA program, two colleagues from his time in the army, and four current colleagues.
Robert then asked these individuals to provide information about his strengths, accompanied by speci c examples of moments when Robert usedthose strengths in ways that were meaningful to them, to their families or teams, or to their organizations. Many people—Robert among them—feeluncomfortable asking for exclusively positive feedback, particularly from colleagues. Accustomed to hearing about their strengths and weaknessessimultaneously, many executives imagine any positive feedback will be unrealistic, even false. Some also worry that respondents might construethe request as presumptuous or egotistical. But once managers accept that the exercise will help them improve their performance, they tend to divein.
Within ten days, Robert received e-mail responses from all 11 people describing speci c instances when he had made important contributions—including pushing for high quality under a tight deadline, being inclusive in communicating with a diverse group, and digging for critical
information. The answers he received surprised him. As a military veteran and a technical person holding an MBA, Robert rarely yielded to hisWHAT TO READ NEXTRemembering Ronald CoaseThe MFA Is the New MBAWasserstein: Remembering an Unlikely HeroicLeaderVIEW MORE FROM THE

January 2005 IssueEXPLORE THE ARCHIVE
How to Play to Your St... 8页 1下载券 How to Play Basketball... ... China 南北中文 SN Mandarin How to play Mahjong Introduction The History of...
How to play lol Lol is mean League of legends, it is a game like ...may be when you go to wc ,you can tell your teammate afk B is mean...
How to Play to Your Stre... 8页 2财富值 when is your birthday 教.... Strengths are how you go here, and without refining and updating, they ...
STRENGTHS 4页 免费 Strengths 4 暂无评价 2页 免费 Learning Strengths 3页 免费 How to Play to Your Stre... 8页 2财富值 仙踪林 Strengths 1页 2财富...
how to play volleyball_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。the three main steps ...The preparation work not only can make sure your score in this game but ...
How To Play Football Number of participants time of the match Football terms ? Midfielder ? 中场 Football terms ? Kick off stopping ? goal kick pass ...
7:20. A. How to keep fit. C. What to play with. A. He doesn’t... or visit a sports medicine center to find out your strengths and ...
STRENGTHS 4页 免费 Strengths 4 暂无评价 2页 免费 Learning Strengths 3页 免费 How to Play to Your Stre... 8页 2财富值 仙踪林 Strengths 1页 2财富...
Strengths 2页 1财富值 Strengths 暂无评价 1页 1财富值 Strengths 4 暂无评价 2页 免费 Learning Strengths 3页 免费 How to Play to Your Stre... 8页 ...
to play with fire, but ___ is difficult is to prevent children from playing...Learn how to dress to emphasize your strengths and improve your employabil...
热门文档