New Correlations for Critical and Subcritical Two-Phase Flow Through Surface Chokes in High-Rate Oil Wells 油田井口临界和亚临界测量关联式
New Correlations for Critical and Subcritical Two-Phase Flow Through Surface Chokes in High-Rate Oil Wells
Hazim H. Al-Attar, SPE, United Arab Emirates University
Summary
The critical and subcritical multiphase flow through wellhead restrictions of a prolific oil field in the Middle East is investigated, and two sets of new correlations are presented. The first set of cor-relations is developed by using 40 field tests representing critical attempt to study cases where the upstream pressure was less than 1.7 times the downstream pressure. He stated that below this level, well performance is sensitive to line pressure (subcritical flow). He also cautioned that small errors in bean size can cause up to a 20% error in the desired upstream pressure. Baxendell (1957), flow conditions. The second set of correlations is based on 139 field tests representing subcritical flow conditions of gas/liquid mixtures through wellhead chokes.
For the critical multiphase flow condition, the predicted oil flow rates by the new set of correlations are in excellent agreement with the measured ones. The absolute average percent difference (AAPD) is between 1.88 and 4.37, and the corresponding standard of deviation (SD) is between 2.52 and 6.52. These results are found to be statistically superior to those predicted by other published correlations considered in this work. During the subcritical gas/liquid flow conditions through surface chokes, the accuracy of oil flow rates predicted by the new set of correlations seems to be sensitive to the type and size of the choke being used. For Cam-eron LD type and 144/64-in. choke, the oil flow rates predicted by the proposed correlation are superior to those predicted by other methods available in the literature, with AAPD of 8.5. However, for smaller choke sizes of 96/64 and 64/64 in., the oil flow rates predicted by the new correlations and other methods are found to be close to each other. For Cameron F type and 144/64-in. choke size, the oil flow rates predicted by the new correlation are closely matched by those predicted by other published methods, with AAPD of 13.7. For smaller choke sizes of 80/64 and 64/64 in., few field tests are available, and the predications of all methods, including the proposed ones, show similar statistical results. The above findings for Cameron F choke also seem to apply to beaned wellhead assemblies for this particular oil field.
Introduction
The main problems associated with multiphase flow through restrictions are calculations of (1) pressure upstream from choke, (2) liquid production rate, or (3) choke diameter. Thus, various developments have been published that present theory and cor-relations for describing simultaneous liquid and gas flow through surface restrictions. Most of these correlations are for critical flow across the choke, and very little work has been done for subcritical flow. The approach used by most investigators may be classified into one of the following:
Empirical correlations from field or laboratory data.
Empirical correlations using dimensional analysis to select and group the most important variables.
Theoretical approaches applying mathematical analysis to a simplified physical model with development of equations.
Gilbert (1954) presented an approximated solution for critical flow through chokes based on regularly reported well production data. He also gave a detailed description of the role of chokes in wells and the interactive use of flowing gradient curves with choke performance curves based on his equation. Gilbert (1954) made no
Copyright © 2010 Society of Petroleum Engineers
This paper (SPE 120788) was accepted for presentation at the Latin American and Caribbean Petroleum Engineering Conference, Cartagena de Indias, Columbia, 31 May–03 June 2009, and revised for publication. Original manuscript received for review 11 January 2009. Revised manuscript received for review 30 April 2009. Paper peer approved 18 May 2009.
March 2010 SPE Projects, Facilities & Construction
Ros (1959), and Achong (1961) published revised forms of the equation proposed by Gilbert (1954) using updated coefficients based on additional data from different oil fields. Ashford (1974) presented a study that was strictly for critical flow through chokes. Assuming polytropic expansion of the gas phase, critical flow occurs at a pressure ratio of 0.544, and a specific heat ratio of 1.04 prevails. He developed an equation for predicting the oil flow rate through a choke. Using field data from 14 flowing well tests, he calculated discharge coefficients necessary to reproduce the field data. Calculated discharge coefficients ranged from 0.642 to 1.218 for choke sizes ranging from 16/64 to 40/64 in. Ashford (1974) claimed that his discharge coefficients were approximately equal to 1.0. Al-Attar and Abdul-Majeed (1988) made a comparison of existing choke critical-flow models using 155 well tests from the east Baghdad oil field. They concluded that the best overall com-parison was obtained with the Gilbert correlation, which predicted measured production rate within an average error of 6.19%.
Fortunati (1972) presented a correlation for subcritical flow that drew heavily from the work of Guzhov and Medviediev (1962). He stated that while critical flow for gas occurs when p2/p1 = 0.5, the critical pressure ratio for two-phase systems can be as low as 0.225 and is highly dependent on g, the no-slip gas holdup. Fortunati’s analysis is based completely on a downstream pressure of approximately 20 psia. Fortunati’s study was applied to 250 field cases. The calculated discharge coefficients agreed well with the range of 1.06 ± 0.12 of those predicted by earlier investigators. Ashford and Pierce (1975) extended the theory of Ros (1960) and developed an equation for subcritical flow-through restrictions. Experiments were run on a flowing well 12,000 ft deep with an Otis J type “22J037” subsurface valve located at 3,500 ft to act as an orifice. Three bean sizes were considered: 14/64, 16/64, and 20/64 in. Pressure bombs were located as close above and below the valve as possible. Considerable difficulties were reported in obtaining reliable data, and discharge coefficients necessary to match measured and theoretical rates showed considerable scatter. The subcritical flow equation was used to prepare several plots of pressure ratio (pp2/p1) vs. oil flow rate (Qo), with choke upstream pressure (1) as a correlating parameter.
In this study, 179 field tests representing wide ranges of flow variables including choke size and type of choke were gathered from a selected prolific oil field in the Middle East and used to develop two sets of empirical correlations for predicting the perfor-mance of two-phase flow through surface chokes. The first set of correlations was developed for critical flow through chokes using 40 field tests. The developed correlations of this set are basically modified forms of Gilbert’s correlation. The second set of correla-tions was developed for subcritical flow through chokes using 139 field tests, and the proposed correlations represent the relationship between the mixture flow rate at downstream conditions (Qm2) vs. the pressure ratio/no-slip holdup factor combination [(p with the choke size (D2/p1)(1–g2)], c) as a correlating parameter. Regression analysis techniques and field-derived solution-gas/oil ratio (GOR) bubblepoint pressure relationship (Rdeveloping the new correlations. Stepwise procedures were then
s–pb) were implemented in 31
OF CORRELATIONS IN SUBCRITICAL POTTS AND RANDOM-...The principal new technique is a form of Russo'...`subcritical' phase from a `supercritical' phase...
Two-phase Flow_公务员考试_资格考试/认证_教育专区... although many empirical correlations for predicting... and a new correlation of Chisholm factor C was...
Correlations of void fraction for two-phase refrigerant flow in pipes_能源...1) Subscripts cr critical exp experimental g gas go gas-only h homogeneous...
predicting critical heat fluxin annular two-phase flow_电力/水利_工程科技_...According to Eq.(1), accurate correlations for the following parameters are...
Simulation of subcritical flow pattern in 180° uniform and convergent open-channel bends using_专业资料。RaolHOBADIso GAN*,mrnMOHAMMADI Kaa 。1De.parme ...
Correlations for Heat Transfer and Flow Friction Characteristics of Compact Plate-Type Heat Exchange_能源/化工_工程科技_专业资料。Correlations for heat ...
ow correlations 1. Introduction Flow control devices are of major importance ... to present a model applicable to both critical and subcritical two-phase ...
two-phase frictional pressure drop correlations ...Supercritical and Subcritical CO2 in Microchannel ...drop, boiling heat transfer, and critical heat ?...
Fluctuations and correlations in hexagonal optical ...1/2 and the critical wave number √ is kc =...The transition is subcritical and the hexagonal ...
for two-phase flow pressure drop in mini-...For refrigerants only, the new correlation and ...1.1. Correlations for common channel (1) ...
热门文档