Background: Multiple groups have reported on the use of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) in treatment-resistant major depression. The purpose of this study is to assess the efficacy of rTMS in unmedicated, treatmentresistant patients who
ARandomizedClinicalTrialofRepetitive
TranscranialMagneticStimulationintheTreatmentofMajorDepression
RobertM.Berman,MeeraNarasimhan,GerardSanacora,AlexanderP.Miano,RalphE.Hoffman,X.SylviaHu,DennisS.Charney,andNashaatN.Boutros
Background:Multiplegroupshavereportedontheuseofrepetitivetranscranialmagneticstimulation(rTMS)intreat-ment-resistantmajordepression.ThepurposeofthisstudyistoassesstheefficacyofrTMSinunmedicated,treatment-resistantpatientswhomeetcriteriaformajordepression.Methods:Depressedsubjects,whohadfailedtorespondtoamedianoffourtreatmenttrials,wereassignedinarandomizeddouble-blindmannertoreceiveeitheractive(n 10;202-sectrainsof20Hzstimulationwith58-secintervals;deliveredat80%motorthresholdwiththefigure-of-eightcoilpositionedovertheleftdorsolateralprefrontalcortex)orsham(n 10;similarconditionswiththecoilelevatedandangled45degreestangentiallytothescalp)rTMS.Thesesequenceswereappliedduring10consecutiveweekdays.Continuouselectroencephalo-gramsamplinganddailymotorthresholddeterminationswerealsoobtained.
Results:Thegroupmean25-itemHamiltonDepressionRatingScale(HDRS)scorewas37.2( 2.0SEM)points.AdjustedmeandecreasesinHDRSscoreswere14.0( 3.7)and0.2( 4.1)pointsfortheactiveandcontrolgroups,respectively(p .05).Oneof10subjectsreceivingactivetreatmentdemonstratedarobustresponse(i.e.,HDRSde-creasedfrom47to7points);threeotherpatientsdemon-strated40–45%decreasesinHDRSscores.Nopatientsreceivingshamtreatmentdemonstratedpartialorfullresponses.
Conclusions:A2-weekcourseofactiverTMSresultedinstatisticallysignificantbutclinicallymodestreductionsofde-pressivesymptoms,ascomparedtoshamrTMSinapopulationcharacterizedbytreatmentresistance.BiolPsychiatry2000;47:332–337©2000SocietyofBiologicalPsychiatry
KeyWords:Majordepression,transcranialmagneticstimulation,randomizedclinicaltrial,medicationresis-tance,neuroanatomy,dorsolateralprefrontalcortex
Introduction
revailinghypothesesonthepathophysiologyofpsy-chiatricillnessessuchasmajordepressivedisorderhavebeenfoundedpredominantlyonreceptor-basedmod-els.Withadvancesinfunctionalneuroimaging,hypothe-sesontheneurocircuitryofdepressionhavebeenoffered(Drevets1998;Mayberg1997).Untilthedevelopmentoftranscranialmagneticstimulation(TMS),nopracticaltoolshavebeenavailabletodirectlyexploitthisunder-standinginthetreatmentofmajordepression.Multiplegroupshavereportedthatrepetitivetranscranialmagneticstimulation(rTMS)maybeefficaciousintreatment-refractorymajordepression.Todate,mostofthesepub-lishedstudiesarelimitedbyeitheropen-labeldesignorinclusionofmedicateddepressedsubjects.Inonereport(Georgeetal1997),activerTMStreatment(80%motorthreshold[MT];20Hz;202-sectrains;58-secoff-intervals;5cmanteriortothepointyieldingmaximalstimulationoftherightabductorpollucisbrevismuscle)resultedingreaterdeclineontheHamiltonDepressionRatingScale(HDRS)thanshamrTMS.Inanotherreport(Pascual-Leoneetal1996),rTMSappliedoverasimilarlydefinedarearesultedinclinicallyandstatisticallysuperiorimprovementindepressivesymptomswhencomparedtofourotherlocations.Morerecentblinded(Kleinetal1999)andopen-labelreportshavealsolentcompellingsupporttotheefficacyofTMSinthetreatmentofmajordepressivedisorder(Epsteinetal1998);however,discor-dantfindingshavealsobeenreported(Looetal1999).ThepurposeofthepresentstudywastoassesstheefficacyofrTMSundercontrolledconditionsinunmedi-cated,treatment-refractorypatientswhometcriteriaformajordepressivedisorder,employingparametersthatwerepreviouslyreportedtobesuccessful.
0006-3223/00/$20.00PIIS0006-3223(99)00243-7
P
FromtheYaleUniversitySchoolofMedicine,DepartmentofPsychiatry(RMB,
MN,GS,APM,REH,XSH,DSC,NNB)andSchoolofEpidemiologyandPublicHealth(XSH),NewHaven;ClinicalNeuroscienceResearchUnit,ConnecticutMentalHealthCenter,NewHaven(RMB,APM,DSC);AffectiveDisordersProgram,VAConnecticutHealthcareSystem,WestHavenCampus,WestHaven(MN,GS,DSC,NNB);andYalePsychiatricInstitute,NewHaven(REH),Connecticut.
AddressreprintrequeststoRobertM.Berman,M.D.,ClinicalNeuroscienceUnit
(Rm.360),ConnecticutMentalHealthCenter,34ParkStreet,NewHaven,CT06519.
ReceivedFebruary26,1999;revisedAugust4,1999;acceptedAugust24,1999.
©2000SocietyofBiologicalPsychiatry
Ef f ects of repetitive transcranial magnet ic stimu lation on [ 11 C] ...A randomized clinical trial of repet i tive transcranial magnetic stimulation ...
(repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation,rTMS) ... stroke patients:a randomized control trial[J]. ...training: from laboratory to clinical setting[J]....
2012 Clinical application of TMS Paolo M. Rossini...randomized to rTMS (10 trains of 3Hz/10secs/...repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) ...
clinical use of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) Utilisation ...Nevertheless, as long as large randomized studies have not been conducted,...
of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation of ...The clinical treatment of the problem child[M]....Randomized trial of a program to enhance the ...
Meta Yang Yu-jie, Second School of Clinical Medicine of Nanjing University ...randomized controlled trials of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation ...
Clinical eectiveness and cost of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation versus ECT in severe depression: A multi-centre randomized controlled trial and ...
Fregni F,Boggio P.A Sham Controlled Trial of a Day Course of Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation of the Unaffected Hemisphere in Stroke Patients[J...
of Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation Treatment in the Treatment of ...negative symptoms of schizophrenia: a randomized controlled pilot study[J]. ...
Should we treat auditory hallucinations with repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation? A metaanalysis. Can J Psychiatry. 2008;53:577–586. 3.Poulet E, ...
热门文档