Reliability Analysis of Earth Dams

ReliabilityAnalysisofEarthDams
G.L.SivakumarBabu,M.ASCE1;andAmitSrivastava2
Abstract:Inthepresentstudy,resultsofreliabilityanalysesoffourselectedrehabilitatedearthdamsections,i.e.,Chang,Tapar,Rudramata,andKaswati,underpseudostaticloadingconditions,arepresented.Usingtheresponsesurfacemethodology,incombinationwith rstorderreliabilitymethodandnumericalanalysis,thereliabilityindex valuesareobtainedandresultsareinterpretedinconjunctionwithconventionalfactorofsafetyvalues.Thein uenceofconsideringvariabilityintheinputsoilshearstrengthparameters,horizontalseismiccoef cient h ,andlocationofreservoirfulllevelonthestabilityassessmentoftheearthdamsectionsisdiscussedintheprobabilisticframework.Acomparisonofresultswiththoseobtainedfromothermethodofreliabilityanalysis,viz.,MonteCarlosimulationscombinedwithlimitequilibriumapproach,providedabasisfordiscussingthestabilityofearthdamsinprobabilisticterms,andtheresultsoftheanalysissuggestthattheconsideredearthdamsectionsarereliableandareexpectedtoperformsatisfactorily.DOI:10.1061/ ASCE GT.1943-5606.0000313
CEDatabasesubjectheadings:Structuralreliability;Dams,earth;Seismiceffects;Damsafety.Authorkeywords:Reliability;Earthendams;Seismiceffects;Damsafety.
Introduction
Therisk-baseddesignproceduresforanalyzingtheroleofuncer-taintiesindamsafetyanalysisarereceivingincreasingimpor-tance InternationalCommitteeonLargeDams ICOLD 1999;Bureau2003 .TheBhujearthquake,intheGujaratstateofIndiain2001,resultedinthefailureorseveredamageofmanyearthdams.Thus,thereisagrowingconsensusforapplyingrisk-baseddesignapproachesfordamsinIndia.Forthestabilityanalysisofearthdamsunderearthquakeconditions,thepseudostaticmethodofanalysisisemployed.TheBureauofIndianStandards BIS2002 BIS1893 providesguidelinesinthisdirection.Indiaisdividedintofourzonesintheincreasingorderofimpact II,III,IV,andV andthedamsthatfailedintheBhujregionofGujaratbelongtoZoneV.Therecommendedvalueofdesignhorizontalseismiccoef cient hisgivenbyZISa/2Rfg,whereZ=zonefac-torwhichistakenas0.36forZoneV;I=importancefactorfordams 1.0forordinaryembankments ;andSa/g=responseaccel-erationcoef cientwhichdependson-siteconditionsandfunda-mentalperiod,anditsvalueisobtainedas2.5.ThetermRfistheresponsereductionfactor,whichistakenas3.0inthecaseofearthdams.Thisleadstoadesigncoef cient h of0.15.Thecodealsospeci esanallowablefactorofsafety FS of1.0forearthdamsunderpseudostaticloading.
ThevariabilityinsoilstrengthandstiffnesscharacteristicsleadstovariabilityintheestimatedpseudostaticFSwhichcanbe
Professor,Dept.ofCivilEngineering,IndianInstituteofScience,Bangalore,India correspondingauthor .E-mail:gls@civil.iisc.ernet.in2
ResearchAssociate,Dept.ofCivilEngineering,IndianInstituteofScience,Bangalore,India.E-mail:amisri@civil.iisc.ernet.in
Note.ThismanuscriptwassubmittedonJuly19,2008;approvedonDecember29,2009;publishedonlineonJanuary5,2010.DiscussionperiodopenuntilDecember1,2010;separatediscussionsmustbesub-mittedforindividualpapers.ThispaperispartoftheJournalofGeo-technicalandGeoenvironmentalEngineering,Vol.136,No.7,July1,2010.©ASCE,ISSN1090-0241/2010/7-995–998/$25.00.
1
addressedusingtheprobabilisticapproach.Intheprobabilisticapproach,thesafetyofagivenstructureisevaluatedeitherintermsoftheprobabilityoffailure pf orreliabilityindex .Areliabilityindexvalueof3.0isacceptableforaboveaverageper-formancelevelandinthecaseofmajorstructures,suchasdams,thevalueof shouldbecloseto5.0 UnitedStatesArmyCorpsofEngineers USACE 1997 .Themethodsfortheestimationofreliabilityindex areavailableinliterature BaecherandChris-tian2003 .
ObjectiveofthePresentStudy
ThereliabilityanalysisofearthdamslocatedintheKachchhregionofGujarat,India,usingtheresponsesurfacemethodology RSM ,incombinationwith rstorderreliabilitymethod FORM andnumericalanalysis,isperformedandresultsarecomparedwiththepreviousresultsobtainedfromthecombina-tionofMonteCarlosimulations MCS andlimitequilibriumapproach.Thestudyhighlights 1 theeffectofcorrelationinsoilparameters; 2 choiceofdistribution normaltolognormal ; 3 seismiclocationofdamsections; 4 variationsinthelocationofthereservoirfulllevel RFL ;and 5 seismicaccelerationactingonthedamsection expressedintermsof h .
ProbabilisticAnalysis
Intheprobabilisticanalysis,anexplicitorimplicitfunctionalre-lationshipbetweeninputparametersandoutputresponseisre-quired,whichissometimesdif culttoestablishexceptforsimplecases.UndersuchconditionstheconceptofRSMcanbeused.RSM
IntheRSMapproach,forarangeofexpectedvariationsintheinputvariables x1,x2,x3... ,anapproximateexplicitfunctional
JOURNALOFGEOTECHNICALANDGEOENVIRONMENTALENGINEERING©ASCE/JULY2010/995
Reliability analysis of earth slopes using hybrid chaotic particle swarm optimization_专业资料。JCetSuhUnvTcn1(o11:6613 .n.ot i.cho.21、812—67DoI1....
(eds) ? 2009 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-49874-6 Reliability analysis of embankment dams using Bayesian network Dianqing Li, Haihao...
and Structural Benefits of Utilizing Reinforced Soil in Earth Dams_专业资料。... Rare Earth Doped Optic... 1人阅读 4页 2.00 Analysis and Flexible ...
FOR EARTH AND ROCK-FILL ... 75页 免费 Reliability Analysis of ... 4... ROCKFILL DAMS WITH EARTH CORES Cássio VIOTTI Consultant Honorary President ...
Division "Gidroproekt" to calculate the stability of earth dams. ... "Modem methods of assessing the reliability and stability of earth dams ...
第30 卷 2008 年 第9期 9月 岩 土 工 程 学 报 Chinese Journal of ...Reliability analysis on seepage stability of earth dams and its application ...
www.elsevier.com/locate/engstruct Diagnostic analysis of concrete dams based...Structural reliability analysis of elastic-plastic structures using neural ...
Freeze (1971) presented a three-dimensional analysis of flow through earth dams that included unsaturated soil domains. The three-dimensional analysis was a...
Analysis and Control for Dams EM 1110-2-1902 Stability of Earth and Rock Fill Dams EM 1110-2-2000 Standard Practice for Concrete for Civil Works ...
热门文档