Coupled Surface-Subsurface Model for Simulating Drainage from Permeable Friction Course Highways
Bradley J. Eck, M.ASCE1; Michael E. Barrett, M.ASCE2; and Randall J. Charbeneau, M.ASCE3
Abstract: Permeable friction course (PFC) is a porous asphalt pavement placed on top of a regular impermeable roadway. Under small rainfall intensities, drainage is contained within the PFC layer; but under higher rainfall intensities, drainage occurs both within and on top of
the porous pavement. A computer model—the permeable friction course drainage code (Perfcode)—is developed to study this two- dimensional unsteady drainage process. Given a hyetograph, geometric information regarding the roadway layout, and hydraulic properties of the PFC media, the model predicts the variation of water depth within and on top of the PFC layer through time. The porous layer is treated as an unconfined aquifer using Darcy’s law and the Dupuit-Forchheimer assumptions. Surface flow is modeled using the diffusion wave
approximation to the Saint-Venant equations. A mass balance approach is used to couple surface and subsurface phases. Straight and curved roadway geometries are accommodated via a curvilinear grid. The model is validated using steady-state solutions that were obtained inde- pendently. Perfcode was applied to a field monitoring site near Austin, Texas, and hydrographs predicted by the model were consistent with
field measurements. For a sample storm studied in detail, PFC reduced the duration of sheet flow conditions by 80%. In a second sample storm, PFC prevented sheet flow conditions completely. The model may be used to improve the drainage design of PFC roadways. DOI: 10 .1061/(ASCE)HY.1943-7900.0000474. © 2012 American Society of Civil Engineers.
CE Database subject headings: Hydraulic models; Porous media; Pavements; Sheet flow; Drainage; Simulation. Author keywords: Hydraulic models; Porous pavement; Sheet flow; Dupuit-Forchheimer.
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by Hohai University Library on 12/16/12. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
Introduction
of an arbitrarily thick porous layer. Additionally, PFC has been shown to clog over time, resulting in lower subsurface drainage
Conventional highways are paved with concrete or asphalt and capacity (NCHRP 2009). Therefore, some storms will exceed drainage occurs across the roadway according to the longitudinal the installed capacity, forcing drainage to occur both on the pave- slope and cross-slope. Drainage may be improved by overlaying ment surface and within the porous matrix. This paper describes a
model for this coupled unsteady drainage process. the roadway with porous asphalt so that drainage occurs within
There are three published predictions of water depth in PFC for the pavement rather than across it. The overlay of porous
asphalt—called permeable friction course (PFC) or open graded straight roadway sections under constant rainfall. Ranieri (2002)
gives a numerical solution to the governing equation and a design friction course—is commonly placed in a 50-mm or thinner layer
chart. Tan et al. (2004) use a commercial finite element program to on top of conventional, impermeable pavement. During rain events,
model flow through PFC. Both Ranieri (2002) and Tan et al. (2004) water seeps into the porous layer and flows to the side of the road
by gravity. By removing water from the road surface, PFC im- provide charts to find the required thickness of PFC from slope
information and rainfall intensity. Charbeneau and Barrett (2008) proves safety by reducing splashing and hydroplaning (Berbee et al.
provide an analytical solution for the saturated thickness along the 1999). In addition to safety benefits, PFC has also been shown to
flow path. reduce pollutants commonly observed in highway runoff (Barrett,
These three papers consider the same roadway geometry: a
2008).
straight road with constant longitudinal slope and cross-slope.
Although usually placed in a 50-mm layer, the PFC thickness
The drainage slope is the Pythagorean sum of the longitudinal slope
may be selected so that all of the rainfall for a design event drains
and the cross-slope. In these papers, the drainage slope is a con-
within the pavement. Structural and cost concerns prevent the use
stant, making the problem one-dimensional (1D). Under constant rainfall intensity, the system reaches a steady state. It is this 1D 1
Postdoctoral Fellow, Center for Research in Water Resources, The
steady-state solution that these writers present. A comparison of Univ. of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX 78712 (corresponding author). E-mail:
their predictions reveals that Charbeneau and Barrett (2008) and bradleyjeck@gmail.com
2 Ranieri (2002) have essentially identical results. Tan et al. (2004) Research Associate Professor, Center for Research in Water Resources,
The Univ. of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX 78712. E-mail: mbarrett@mail obtain a different result, predicting a thinner porous layer than the .utexas.edu other workers. The reasons for this discrepancy are difficult to un- 3
Professor of Civil Engineering, Center for Research in Water cover because Tan et al. (2004) used a commercial finite element Resources, The Univ. of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX 78712. E-mail: program for analysis. charbeneau@mail.utexas.edu
Very little has been mentioned in the literature regarding
Note. This manuscript was submitted on July 12, 2010; approved on
the coupling between surface and subsurface flow in PFCs.
June 13, 2011; published online on June 15, 2011. Discussion period open
Charbeneau and Barrett (2008) address the issue briefly and until June 1, 2012; separate discussions must be submitted for individual
provide an estimate of sheet flow thickness on the basis of the papers. This paper is part of the Journal of Hydraulic Engineering,
Darcy-Weisbach equation. Eck et al. (2011) refined the coupling Vol. 138, No. 1, January 1, 2012. ©ASCE, ISSN 0733-9429/2012/1-
between PFC and sheet flow by using a different boundary 13–22/$25.00.
JOURNAL OF HYDRAULIC ENGINEERING © ASCE / JANUARY 2012 / 13
热门文档