1. Introduction
A Comparison of Two Approaches to Pure-Inertial and Doppler-Inertial Error Analysis DONALD 0. BENSON, JR., Member, IEEE The Analytic Sciences Corporation Reading, Mass. 01867
Abstract Error equations for inertial navigation systems are derived using a perturbation (or true frame) approach and a psi angle (or computer frame) approach in a manner which shows the underlying as sumptions and allows direct comparison of the two methods. The comparison is general since the analysis is not associated with any particular mechanization. Different definitions of velocity errors and misalignment angles result from the two methods of error analysis, and, consequently, have significance in testing and analysis of pure-inertial systems, Doppier-inertial systems, and inertially aided weapon delivery systems. Examples and numerical results are presented for a local-level north-pointing mechanization.
Error equations for inertial navigation systems have been derived in many references using a perturbation (or true frame) approach[1],[2] and a psi angle (or computer frame) approach[3],[4]. A direct comparison showing the equivalence of the two methods does not appear to be available in the literture. The purpose of this paper then is to derive both forms of the error equations in such a way as to clearly define assumptions and compare the perturbation approach with the psi angle approach. Many references use one or the other of these approaches to analyze particular systems. For example,[6] derives error equations for a space-stable system by perturbation analysis and compares the error propagation to local-level systems in[71. Important consequences of comparing the two error analysis approaches are the relations between the variables when either of the approaches is used in practice. Such useful applications are testing and simulation of high-speed inertial systems, evaluation of inertially aided weapon delivery systems, and the expression for velocity divergence when, for example, Doppler velocity measurements are combined with the inertial system indication of velocity. Inertial navigation systems basically solve Newton's force equations from measurements (accelerometer outputs) of specific force (nongravitational acceleration) coordinatized in a frame whose orientation with respect to an inertial frame is controlled or known via gyroscopes. For terrestrial navigation, the equations in terms of ground velocity in an arbitrary rotating frame are
((ie dV/dtIr±++ wir) X and
V-g=f
(1) (2)
V= dR/dte= dR/dtIr+ Wer X R
where V= velocity with respect to Earth f= specific force g= plumb-bob gravity Wie= Earth rate Wir= angular velocity of the r frame with respect to an Earth-centered inertial frame' Wer= angular velocity of the r frame with respect to an Earth-fixed frame R= position vector from the center of the Earth, as shown in Fig. 1 d/dtIe; r= derivative in an Earth-fixed e frame or an arbitrary rotating r frame, respect
ively. Manuscript received October 7, 1974. Copyright 1975 by IEEE Trans. Aerospace and Electronic Systems, vol. AES-1 1, no. 4, July 1975. IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON AEROSPACE AND ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
'
Definitions of suitable inertial frames are found in[5] . VOL. AES-1 1, NO. 4 JULY 1975 447

TOWARDS SEMANTIC INTEROPERABILTY In-depth comparison of two approaches to solving Semantic Web Service Challenge mediation tasks Maciej Zaremba, Tomas Vitvar, ...
A Comparison of BWT Approaches to String Pattern Matching Andrew Firth? Tim Bell? Amar Mukherjee? and Don Adjeroh§ , , , Abstract Recently a number ...
COMPARISON OF APPROACHES TO CONTINUOUS HAND GESTURE RECOGNITION FOR A VISUAL DIALOG SYSTEM Continuous hand gesture recognition requires the detection of ...
[6] P. Eklund, A Comparison of Lattice-theoretic Approaches to Fuzzy Topology, Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 19 (1986), 81–87. 1 [7] P. Eklund, ...
Comparison of the Extended and Sigma-point Kalman Filters on Inertial ...measurements, including the pseudorange and Doppler, and the broadcast ...
Market segmentation in wine tourism-a comparison of approaches_经济/市场_经管营销_专业资料。葡萄酒旅游市场研究TOURISMOS: AN INTERNATIONAL MULTIDISCIPLINARY ...
A comparison of statistical learning approaches ...ti ? for which the error is less than have...(19) describes inertial effects and stems from ...
Saxena and Kamal Raj Pardasani 23 A COMPARISON BETWEEN HYBRID APPROACHES OF ...two layers the error correction learning will be explained by the following ...
6 ANN training window Comparison of Two Approaches with Different Data Requirements 47 a ?xed, ?nite set of input-output pattern, the total error in ...
inertial forces expected in the building during an...The comparison of Traditional approaches with those...The standard error (S.E.) through the whole ...
热门文档