文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 工程科技 > 能源/化工 > Neural basis of semantic and syntactic interference in sentence comprehension 2
侵权投诉

Neural basis of semantic and syntactic interference in sentence comprehension 2

Neural basis of semantic and syntactic interference in sentence comprehension 2

ShortCommunication

Event-relatedbrainpotentialevidenceforanimacyprocessingasymmetriesduringsentence

Neural basis of semantic and syntactic interference in sentence comprehension 2

comprehension

ManteS.Nieuwlanda,b, ,AndreaE.Martina,b,ManuelCarreirasa,b,c

a

DepartmentofPsychology,UniversityofEdinburgh,UKBasqueCenteronCognition,BrainandLanguage,UKc

IKERBASQUE.BasqueFoundationforScience,UK

b

articleinfoabstract

Theanimacydistinctionisdeeplyrootedinthelanguagefaculty.Akeyexampleisdifferentialobjectmarking,thephenomenonwhereanimatesententialobjectsreceivespeci cmarking.Weusedevent-relatedpotentialstoexaminetheneuralprocessingconsequencesofcase-markingviolationsonanimateandinanimatedirectobjectsinSpanish.Inanimateobjectswithincorrectprepositionalcasemarker‘a’(‘alsuelo’)elicitedaP600effectcomparedtounmarkedobjects,consistentwithpreviousliterature.How-ever,animateobjectswithouttherequiredprepositionalcasemarker(‘elobispo’)onlyelicitedanN400effectcomparedtomarkedobjects.Thisnovel nding,anexclusiveN400modulationbyastraightfor-wardgrammaticalruleviolation,doesnotfollowfromextantneurocognitivemodelsofsentenceprocess-ing,andmirrorsunexpected‘‘semanticP600’’effectsforthematicallyproblematicsentences.Theseresultsmayre ectanimacyasymmetryincompetitionforargumentprominence:followingthearticle,thematicinterpretationdif cultiesareelicitedonlybyunexpectedlyanimateobjects.

Ó2013ElsevierInc.Allrightsreserved.

Articlehistory:

Accepted22April2013

Availableonline4June2013Keywords:

SentencecomprehensionElectrophysiologyAnimacyCase

DifferentialobjectmarkingSpanish

Event-relatedpotentialsN400P600

1.Introduction

Knowledgeaboutanimacyisanessentialwayinwhichhumancognitioncarvesuptheworldintonaturalkinds.Itisnotsurprisingthenthatanimacyaffectshowpeoplecommunicateabouttheworld.Animacyexpressesitselfinsomeformoranotherinthemajorityoftheworld’slanguages(e.g.,Dahl&Fraurud,1996).InEnglish,forexample,animateentitiesareusuallyproducedassub-jectsandinearlysentencepositions(e.g.,Prat-Sala&Branigan,2000),mirroredbyprocessingcostsforsentence-initialinanimateobjectsduringcomprehension(e.g.,Weckerly&Kutas,1999).Moreover,somelanguagesrealizeanimacyintheircasesystemsuchthatanimateandinanimatenounphrasesreceivedifferentcasemarkingassententialobject(‘differentialobjectmarking’;Bossong,1991;seealsoAissen,2003;Malchukov,2008).Inthecur-rentstudy,weexamineeffectsofdifferentialobjectmarkingononlinesentencecomprehensionusingevent-relatedpotentials(ERPs).

Anessentialpartofsentencecomprehensionisdistinguishingthesententialargumentsandinterpretingtheirrespectivethe-maticroles(i.e.,establishing‘whodoeswhattowhom’;seeBornkessel-Schlesewsky&Schlesewsky,2009;Dowty,1991;Correspondingauthor.Address:DepartmentofPsychology,Universityof

Edinburgh,7GeorgeSquare,EdinburghEH89JZ,UK.

E-mailaddress:m.nieuwland@ed.ac.uk(M.S.Nieuwland).

Neural basis of semantic and syntactic interference in sentence comprehension 2

0093-934X/$-seefrontmatterÓ2013ElsevierInc.Allrightsreserved.doc.guandang.net

Primus,2011).Inmanylanguages,especiallythosewithrelativelyfreewordorder,thematicinterpretationisguidedbyacasesystemthatmarksthegrammaticalfunctionsofargumentssuchassubjectandobject(e.g.,Fillmore,1968).Thematicinterpretationinlan-guageswithoutanelaboratecasesystem,however,ismorestronglydrivenbyargumentprominence(VanValin,2005),whichcorrelateswithfactorssuchaswordorder,animacyandde nite-ness.Animate,de niteand rst-mentionedentitiesaremoreprominentthaninanimate,inde niteandlater-mentionedentities.Accordingtothedistinctnessprinciple(e.g.,Bornkessel-Schlesewsky&Schlesewsky,2009;Lamers&DeHoop,2005;Primus,2011),thematicroleidenti cationisfacilitatedwhenallargumentsinadescribedeventareasdistinctaspossiblefromoneanotherintermsofallavailabledimensionsofprominence.Thesentence‘‘Johnateanapple’’iscanonicalbecauseitdescribesade nite,ani-matesubjectfollowedbyaninde nite,inanimateobject,whereas‘‘TheappledisgustedJohn’’isatypicalbecauseitcontainsanani-mateobjectthatismoreagentivethanthesubject.Importantly,ifsententialargumentsresembleeachotherinoneormoredimen-sionsofprominence,thematicroleidenti cationmightbehampered,asmaybeobservedinsomeformofprocessingcost.ThishypothesishasreceivedsupportfromERPstudiesontheprocessingofanimacyandcaseinformationduringGermansen-tencecomprehension(e.g.,Frisch&Schlesewsky,2001;Frisch&Schlesewsky,2005).FrischandSchlesewsky(2001)reportedanN400effectplussubsequentP600effectforsentenceswithcase

第1页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email