文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 工程科技 > 能源/化工 > Neural basis of semantic and syntactic interference in sentence comprehension 2
侵权投诉

Neural basis of semantic and syntactic interference in sentence comprehension 2

jects)thatgaverisetoaP600effect.Thisisessentiallydifferentfrompreviousstudies,whichinvolvedexplicitthematiccon ictfromidenticalcase-markings.Becausetheasymmetryofanimacyandobjectmarkingarecoextended,though,wecannotteaseapartthedifferentialimpactofanimateversusinanimatenounsandthedifferentialimpactofneglectingversusover-applicationofthisparticulargrammaticalrule(seealsoChoudharyetal.,2009).

Anotherdifferenceisthatourparticipantsansweredsimplecomprehensionquestions(whichwereunrelatedtothecriticalmanipulation),whereasparticipantsinpreviouswork(e.g.,Frisch&Schlesewsky,2001;Frisch&Schlesewsky,2005;seealsoFrenzeletal.,2011)explicitlyevaluatedsentencewell-formedness.Expli-citjudgmenttasksmightalterhowparticipantsprocesslanguageascomparedtowithoutasecondarytask,and,moreover,tendtoelicitpositiveERPcomponentsatcritical-wordsevenifresponsesarepost-sentence(e.g.,Roehm,Bornkessel-Schlesewsky,Rösler,&Schlesewsky,2007;seealsoKuperberg,2007).Duetosummationofelectricalsignalsatthescalpandpotentialspatio-temporaloverlapofcomponents,task-inducedpositivecomponentscandampenordistortN400activity,whereastheycanenhance(butalsodistort)P600effects.Thus,whereasP600activityinthecur-rentstudycannotbeascribedtoasecondarytask,itisanopenquestionwhetherandtowhatextentP600effectsreportedforcasecon ictsinotherstudiescan.

Finally,theabsenceofaP600effectmightbeafunctionoftheearliersemanticprocessingdif cultiesincurredbytheunexpect-edlyanimateobjects.Becauseourlanguagecomprehensionsystemhasonlylimitedprocessingcapacity,participants’focusonre-establishingacoherentsemanticinterpretationmayhavedivertedtheirattentionfromthe‘smallerconcern’ofthesyntacticallyprob-lematicutterance(forasimilarresult,seeNieuwland&VanBer-kum,2008).Thiscouldbetrueespeciallyintheabsenceofagrammaticalityjudgmenttask.Thefactthatmarkedinanimateob-jectsdidelicitaP600effectsuggeststhatparticipantswereindeedsensitivetotheungrammaticalnatureofthosesentencesevenintheabsenceofsuchatask.ThisP600effect,indexingsyntacticpro-cessingdif culty(Osterhoutetal.,2012)orpossiblyreanalysis(e.g.,Kaanetal.,2000),hadatypicalcentral-posteriorscalpdistri-butionasseenforothertypesofsyntacticmanipulations.4.3.Implicationsfortheelectrophysiologyoflanguage

Ofcentralimportancetoaneurobiologicaltheoryoflanguageisanunderstandingofthemechanismsbywhichpeopleapplytheparticulargrammarofalanguagetoproduceandcomprehendmulti-wordutterances(e.g.,Bornkessel-Schlesewsky&Schlesew-sky,2009;Hagoort,Brown,&Osterhout,1999).Theelectrophysio-logicalstudyoflanguageaimstorevealhowtheseprocessesunfoldinreal-time,by,forexample,tryingtomapelectrophysio-logicalmarkerscorrespondingtospeci csub-processes,andthenusingthesemarkerstostudyhowcomprehensionisaffectedmod-ulatedbythenatureofthelinguisticmaterialandthecontextinwhichitispresented(e.g.,Kutasetal.,2006;Osterhout&Nicol,1999;Osterhoutetal.,1997).Researchersinthis eldhavelongas-sumedthatsemanticprocessingandsyntacticprocessingarereli-ablyindexedbytheN400andP600ERPcomponent,respectively(e.g.,Friederici,1995;Hagoort,2003).However,recentresearchhasshownthatsemanticanomaliessometimeselicitP600effectsinsteadofN400modulations(e.g.,Bourguignon,Drury,Valois,&Steinhauer,2012;Hoeks,Stowe,&Doedens,2004;Kim&Osterh-out,2005;Kuperberg,Kreher,Sitnikova,Caplan,&Holcomb,2007;Nieuwland&VanBerkum,2005;Nieuwland&VanBerkum,2008;VanHerten,Kolk,&Chwilla,2005;forreview,seeBornkes-sel-Schlesewsky&Schlesewsky,2008;Brouwer,Fitz&Hoeks,2012;Kuperberg,2007).Forexample,thesentence‘‘Theheartymealwasdevouring’’issemanticallyanomalousbecausemeals

cannotdevour,butthistypeofsentenceelicitsaP600effectratherthantheexpectedN400effect(e.g.,Kim&Osterhout,2005).Suchresultssuggestthatparticipantsconsiderthistypeofsentenceassyntacticallyincorrect(i.e.,thesuf x‘-ing’shouldbe‘-ed’),the-maticallyreinterpretingthemealaspatientratherthanagent.Theseunexpected‘‘semanticP600’’effectscanbesaidtobemir-roredbythecurrentobservationthatstraightforwardsyntacticanomalieselicitonlyanN400effectinsteadoftheexpectedP600effect.Theseresultsfurtherchipawayatastraightforwardcorrela-tionbetweenexperimenter-de nedlevelsofinterpretationasbeingsemanticorsyntactic,andobservationofN400andP600ef-fectsrespectively.5.Conclusions

WeobservedanN400effectforincorrectlycase-markedani-mateobjects,butaP600effectforincorrectlycase-markedinani-mateobjects.Theseresultstestifytothepotentialimportanceofinvestigatingtheonlineprocessingcorrelatesofinterpretively-rel-evantgrammaticalrules(seealsoChoudharyetal.,2009).More-over,ourresultssupportneurocognitivetheoriesofsentenceprocessingthatcanprioritizeprominence,suchthatchangesinprominenceresultinanimacyprocessingasymmetries,evenwhenthesechangesdonotnecessarilyaffecthowpeopleestablish‘whodoeswhattowhom’.Acknowledgments

WethankJaviMiquelez,SaioaLarraza,EnekoAntón,EriTakah-ashi,LarraitzLopez,ItzalUranga,AlazneAlegre,andDavidCarcedofortheirhelp.MSNwassupportedbyPSI2010-18087/RYC-2011-08628.AEMwassupportedbyJCI-2011-10228.MCwassupportedbyCONSOLIDER-INGENIO2010-CSD2008-00048.AppendixA.Supplementarymaterial

Supplementarydataassociatedwiththisarticlecanbefound,intheonlineversion,atdoc.guandang.net

Aissen,J.(2003).Differentialobjectmarking:IconicityvsEconomy.Natural

LanguageandLinguisticTheory,21,435–483.

Bornkessel-Schlesewsky,I.,&Schlesewsky,M.(2008).Analternativeperspectiveon

‘semanticP600’effectsinlanguagecomprehension.BrainResearchReviews,59,55–73.

Bornkessel-Schlesewsky,I.,&Schlesewsky,M.(2009).Theroleofprominence

informationinthereal-timecomprehensionoftransitiveconstructions:Across-linguisticapproach.LanguageandLinguisticsCompass,3,19–58.

Bossong,G.(1991).DifferentialobjectmarkinginRomanceandbeyond.InD.

Wanner&D.Kibbee(Eds.),Newanalysesinromancelinguistics:selectedpapersfromtheXVIIIlinguisticsymposiumonromancelanguages,Urbana–Champaign,April7–9,1988.Amsterdam:JohnBenjamins.

Bourguignon,N.,Drury,J.E.,Valois,D.,&Steinhauer,K.(2012).Decomposing

animacyreversalsbetweenagentsandexperiencers:AnERPstudy.BrainandLanguage,122(3),179–189.

Brouwer,H.,Fitz,H.,&Hoeks,J.C.J.(2012).Gettingrealaboutsemanticillusions:

RethinkingthefunctionalroleoftheP600inlanguagecomprehension.BrainResearch,1446,127–143.

Casado,P.,Martín-Loeches,M.,Muñoz,F.,&Fernández-Frías,C.(2005).Are

semanticandsyntacticcuesinducingthesameprocessesintheidenti cationofwordorder?CognitiveBrainResearch,24,526–543.

Choudhary,K.K.,Schlesewsky,M.,Roehm,D.,&Bornkessel-Schlesewsky,I.(2009).

TheN400asacorrelateofinterpretively-relevantlinguisticrules:EvidencefromHindi.Neuropsychologia,47,3012–3022.

Coulson,S.,King,J.,&Kutas,M.(1998).Expecttheunexpected:Event-relatedbrain

responsestomorphosyntacticviolations.LanguageandCognitiveProcesses,13,21–58.

Dahl,Ö.,&Fraurud,K.(1996).Animacyingrammaranddiscourse.InThorstein

Fretheim&JeanetteK.Gundel(Eds.),Referenceandreferentaccessibility(pp.47–64).Amsterdam:JohnBenjamins.

上一页第4页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email