“I have always wished that my computer would be as easy to use as my telephone. My wish has come true. I no longer know how to use my telephone.” – Bjarne Stroustrop (originator of C++) As household appliances grow in complexity and sophistication, they
set of relational atoms.3 The planner is given the following ground
problem:
Init = Ψ; Goal = CWA(Ψ- {ti} ∪ {ti’})
The reason for grounding the goal during the translation step is somewhat subtle. The SQL UPDATE command’s SET clause refers to the goal state, i.e. the desired state of the device after the plan has been executed. In contrast, the WHERE clause refers to the state of the device before any changes are made; that is, it refers to the device state at the commencement of planning. Unfortunately, PDDL has no notation for making this distinction4, so if the translation step left any universally quantified variables in the resulting goal, they would all refer to the goal state, or the state after the plan.
4.1 Safety Revisited
We include Ψ as part of the goal to ensure that the planner doesn’t generate a plan that has the nasty side effect of falsifying something that is currently true. For example, the simplest plan to delete all old messages is to delete all messages, new and old (the phone has a single command to do this). By explicitly stating in the goal that new messages should not be deleted, we force the planner to come up with a safe plan. Similarly, we would not want the planner to respond to “call Sue” by first randomly recording a new answering machine greeting, and only then placing the call. Thus, we prevent the planner from unwanted positive side effects by computing the CWA. In domains where resource usage or other side effects are necessary, one can exclude predicates describing these resources from the goal.
As an example of this reduction in action, consider the operation of our Panasonic phone NLIA on the sentence, “Delete all my old messages.” Assume that this NLIA is given the actions from Figure 1 and the database fragment from Table 1 as part of its inputs. The NLIDB translates the input sentence into the SQL statement:
UPDATE message_list SET message = Blank WHERE message = Old.
Our translator takes this SQL statement and performs the syntactic manipulation required to rewrite it as a grounded goal in PDDL. Let <old-msg-num-1> through <old-msg-num-n> represent the numbers of all the old messages in the message_number column of table message_list, and let <new-msg-num-1> through <new-msg-num-m> represent the numbers of all the new messages. In PDDL the grounded goal looks like:
(and (not (message-list <old-msg-num-1> Old)) (message-list <old-msg-num-1> Blank)
…
(not (message-list <old-msg-num-n> Old)) (message-list <old-msg-num-n> Blank) (message-list <new-msg-num-1> Old) …
(message-list <new-msg-num-m> Old))
For brevity’s sake, we omit the other relations in the database from the above goal. The planner takes this goal, together with the initial
Figure 2: Building an NLIA out of an NLIDB and a Planner. The gray box depicts the NLIA.
If the SQL is an update, the translator converts it into a goal in the planning language, which is then sent to the planner to generate a sequence of actions from A. When these actions are executed on the appropriate devices (and also when exogenous events occur), DB is updated to ensure correspondence with the device’s actual state. We are able to skip the translation and planning stages in the case of a SELECT query because of our assumption that the database contains the complete state of the appliance. If this assumption were not met, it might be the case that several actions would have to be taken before the action that answers the query, and such a case would require planning.
The translation step, converting from an SQL update statement to a goal, requires some explanation. As Reiter has shown [22], database updates can be modeled using the situation calculus; for our purposes PDDL suffices also.
Without loss of generality, suppose that DB has relational schema X = {X1, …, Xn}, where each relation Xj has attributes aj1, …, ajk, where k varies from table to table. DB contains a set of tuples satisfying each Xj and because of our earlier assumption regarding notification of exogenous events, we can make the closed world assumption [23].
An SQL update statement has the form:
UPDATE Xj
SET a1=c1, …, au=cu WHERE am=cm, …, an=cn
where the ai are attributes of Xj, and the ci are constants. We can convert this SQL statement into a PDDL goal with a process similar to that used for generating a propositional form for a universally quantified goal in classical planning [27]. The first step is running the following SQL query on DB, the agent’s model of the device.
SELECT DISTINCT a1, …, ak FROM Xj
WHERE am=cm, …, an=cn
Execution of this query will retrieve a set of tuples, {ti}, whose values need to be modified. Let {ti’} denote the corresponding set of tuples obtained by changing the value of the jth attribute of each tuple to cj, for all m ≤ j ≤ n. Let Ψ denote the set of all tuples in DB, and let CWA denote the function which computes the closure of a
Closing a set of positive literals means explicitly adding the negation of any atom, which is absent from the set. If the set of relations and constants is finite and there are no function symbols (which is our case), this operation takes polynomial time. 4
See, for instance, SADL [8] for an action description language that does provide notation to distinguish between the initial and goal states.
3

A Reliable Natural Langu... 暂无评价 8页 免费 Application of Natural L.... Developing a Natural Language Interface to Complex Data GARY G. HENDRIX, ...
A Natural Language Inter... 暂无评价 4页 免费 A Reliable Natural Langu....Interface to Data management (EUFID) system, a n a t u r a l - l ...
Many of the seniors language has reached a level...interface circuits,to highlingt the target of ...3.In the applicationof household appliances It ...
A visualization of small high-level language ...interface circuits, highlight the object of ... household appliances, medical equipment, aerospace,...
reliable news 新闻/通讯稿 news release 头条新闻 ...interface 无线掌上导航器 wireless palm pilot 蜂窝...household electrical appliances 局域网 Intranet 网站...
Many high-level language has reached the level ...interface circuits, highlight the object of ...In Household Appliances can be said that the ...
Many high-level language has reached the level ..., navigation systems, and household appliances. ...interface circuits, highlight the object of ...
code language, and as so low why is the use?..., navigation systems, and household appliances. ...interface circuits, highlight the object of ...
Many high-level language has reached the level ...interface circuits, highlight the object of ...In Household Appliances can be said that the ...
Many high-level language has reached the level ...interface circuits, highlight the object of ...In Household Appliances Can be said that the ...
热门文档