文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 自然科学 > Performance_of_microarray_and_liquid_based_capture_methods_for_target_enrichment_for_massively_paral
侵权投诉

Performance_of_microarray_and_liquid_based_capture_methods_for_target_enrichment_for_massively_paral

关于芯片测序方面方法

TargetEnrichmentMethodComparison

bebestsuitedforvariantdiscoveryinaregionofinterestthatconsistedofcontinuousgenomicintervals.

Specificityanduniformityofthecapturingprocessdefinehowmuchover-samplingisneededtoadequatelycoverasequencinglibrary.Inourhands,54%ofthesequencereadsalignedtothetargetedregion,whenthesequencinglibrarieswerepreparedusingtheNimblegenmethodand74%,whenthelibrarieswerepreparedusingtheSureSelectmethod,onaverage.BasedonthesepercentageswecancalculatethatifthelibraryispreparedusingtheNimblegenmethod,approximately1.4-foldmoreover-samplingisrequiredtoobtainanygivenaveragecoveragethanifthelibraryispreparedusingtheSureSelectmethod.Weobtainedsimilaruniformitywithbothmethods,whichisinagreementwiththeresultsofanotherstudythatcomparedthesameenrichmentmethodsinexonicregionsandconservedelements[42].Coverageuniformityisimportantsothatonedoesnotneedtowaistsequencingcapacityforover-sequencingofsomeregionsinordertoobtainadequatecoverageofothers.Ashasbeenpreviouslyshownforhybridizationbasedsequencecapture[42],weobtainedhighuniformitywithbothmethods.

ThemajordifferencebetweenourstudyandthestudybyTeeretal.thatconcentratedonexonsandconservedregions[42]isthatwewereabletodesignNimblegenprobesfor78%andAgilentprobesfor55%ofourregionofinterest,whereasTeeretal.wereabletodesignprobesfor94%and92.6%oftheirregionofinterestforNimblegenandAgilent,respectively[42].Duetothisdifferenceintheprobedesignsbetweenthetwomethods,werecoveredaconsiderably(0.6Mb)largerpropor-tionoftheoriginaltargetregionfromtheNimblegenlibraries.Todefinerepeats,AgilentusesRepeatMasker.RepeatMaskerdefinesrepeatsaccordingtodifferentcriteriathanthein-housealgorithmthatNimblegenuses,whichexplainsthedifferencesintheprobetargetedregionsbetweenthetwomethods.WecouldrecoveraslightlylargerproportionoftheprobetargetedregionsfromtheSureSelectlibrariesandaslightlylargerproportionofthenon-repeatedpartofthetargetedregionfromtheNimblegenlibraries.ThiswassurprisingsinceAgilentusedRepeatMaskertoexcluderepeatsfromtheSureSelectdesignandwealsousedRepeatMaskertodefinetherepeatswhenweanalyzedthenon-repeatedportionofourtargetregion.Itislikelythattheregions,whichareincludedintheNimblegendesign,butexcludedfromtheSureSelectdesign,aremoredifficulttocapture.Itwouldbeinterestingtocomparethetwomethodsemployingthesamerepeatmaskingstrategyforbothtoseehowthatwouldinfluencetheresults.ItispossibletosubmitanalreadyRepeatMaskedregiontoNimblegenforadesignandacustomrepeatmaskingoptioniscurrentlyavailablewhenorderingSureSelectcaptureprobes,butitisdependentonextrabioinformaticsworkbythecustomer.Bettercoverageofthewholetargetregionwillbeincreasinglyimportantasthesequencingreadlengthgetslongerandreadscanbealignedtomorerepeatedregions.

WecalledmoreknownandnovelSNPsfromtheNimblegenlibrariesthanfromtheSureSelectlibrariesineachsample,whichisexpectedsincewealsosequencedalargerproportionofthetargetregionfromthoselibraries.WeobservedslightlybetterconcordancebetweenourSNPcallsandtheHapMapgenotypesfromtheSureSelectlibraries,whichisprobablyduetothelargerpercentageofreadsmappingtothetargetedregionandthetargetedregionbeingsmallerintheSureSelectlibraries.ThesetwofactorscombinedleadtohigheraveragecoverageintheSureSelectlibrariesdespitethedownsamplingofthenumberof

sequencereadsintheSureSelectlibrariestoequalthoseintheNimblegenlibrariesinthebeginningoftheanalysis.OurSNPcallsfrombothtypesofsequencinglibrariescorrelatedverywellwiththeHapMapgenotypesontheindividuallevelreflectingthehighqualityoftheSNPcalls.Tenoutofthe11discrepantcallsthatwereinvestigatedbySangersequencingfurtheragreedwithoursequencedata.OurSNPcallsalsocorrelatedverywellwiththedatainEnsemblvariationaswellaswiththeSNPcallsfromthe1000genomesproject.InadditiontobeinggenotypedbytheHapMapproject,theparentsofthetriothatwesequencedherearepartofthe1000genomespilotonecohortof180unrelatedindividualsthathavebeensequencedtolowcoverage.ThisexplainswhywefindsofewnovelSNPsinoursamples.Nevertheless,wedofindsomenewSNPshighlightingtheimportanceofhighcoveragesequencingtodetectallthevariationinaparticularregion.

Particularlywhenalargenumberofsamplesaretobesequenced,practicalconsiderationsareimportantinthechoiceofthesequenceenrichmentmethod.TheSureSelecthybridcaptureprotocolisfasterandeasiertoperformthantheNimblegenprotocol,whichisageneraldifferencebetweenarrayandsolutionbasedcapturemethodsratherthanbetweenthesetwomethodsinparticular.Anotheradvantageofliquid-basedcapturemethodsisthattheyareeasiertomultiplexandautomatethanarraybasedones.Multiplexingandautomationwillbecomemoreimportantinthefuture,especiallywhentargetedsequencingisbeingusedinsteadofgenotypinginstudiesinvolvingalargenumberofsamples.SolutionbasedcapturemethodsalsorequiresmalleramountsofinputDNA,whichisespeciallyimportantwhenclinicalsamplesarestudied.

Takentogether,ourresultsshowthatthestrengthsoftheSureSelectmethodarebetterspecificityandreproducibility,andthestrengthoftheNimblegenmethodisbetteroverallcoverageoftheoriginaltargetregion,whichalsoresultsinalargernumberofSNPcallspersample.ThusNimblegen’smethodperformedbetterindiscoveringvariantsinourtargetregion.Weconcludethatrepeatmaskingandprobedesignareimportantparameterswhenonewantstocaptureallthevariationinagivenregion.Combiningthestrengthsofbothmethodsshouldbeusefulinthefurtherdevelopmentofsequencecapturemethodsformassivelyparallelsequencinginthefuture.

SupportingInformation

TableS1PrimersequencesforSangersequencing.

(DOC)

TableS2NovelSNPs.

(XLS)

Acknowledgments

SequencingwasperformedusingtheGAIIXequipmentattheSNP&SEQTechnologyPlatforminUppsala.WethankMarieLinderssonandKristinaLarssonforassistancewithsequencingandJessicaNordlundforreviewingthelanguageofthemanuscript.

AuthorContributions

Conceivedanddesignedtheexperiments:AKA-CS.Performedtheexperiments:AKAA.Analyzedthedata:OKAKKL-T.Contributedreagents/materials/analysistools:SS.Wrotethepaper:AKOKAASSKL-TA-CS.

上一页第9页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email