关于芯片测序方面方法
TargetEnrichmentMethodComparison
bebestsuitedforvariantdiscoveryinaregionofinterestthatconsistedofcontinuousgenomicintervals.
Specificityanduniformityofthecapturingprocessdefinehowmuchover-samplingisneededtoadequatelycoverasequencinglibrary.Inourhands,54%ofthesequencereadsalignedtothetargetedregion,whenthesequencinglibrarieswerepreparedusingtheNimblegenmethodand74%,whenthelibrarieswerepreparedusingtheSureSelectmethod,onaverage.BasedonthesepercentageswecancalculatethatifthelibraryispreparedusingtheNimblegenmethod,approximately1.4-foldmoreover-samplingisrequiredtoobtainanygivenaveragecoveragethanifthelibraryispreparedusingtheSureSelectmethod.Weobtainedsimilaruniformitywithbothmethods,whichisinagreementwiththeresultsofanotherstudythatcomparedthesameenrichmentmethodsinexonicregionsandconservedelements[42].Coverageuniformityisimportantsothatonedoesnotneedtowaistsequencingcapacityforover-sequencingofsomeregionsinordertoobtainadequatecoverageofothers.Ashasbeenpreviouslyshownforhybridizationbasedsequencecapture[42],weobtainedhighuniformitywithbothmethods.
ThemajordifferencebetweenourstudyandthestudybyTeeretal.thatconcentratedonexonsandconservedregions[42]isthatwewereabletodesignNimblegenprobesfor78%andAgilentprobesfor55%ofourregionofinterest,whereasTeeretal.wereabletodesignprobesfor94%and92.6%oftheirregionofinterestforNimblegenandAgilent,respectively[42].Duetothisdifferenceintheprobedesignsbetweenthetwomethods,werecoveredaconsiderably(0.6Mb)largerpropor-tionoftheoriginaltargetregionfromtheNimblegenlibraries.Todefinerepeats,AgilentusesRepeatMasker.RepeatMaskerdefinesrepeatsaccordingtodifferentcriteriathanthein-housealgorithmthatNimblegenuses,whichexplainsthedifferencesintheprobetargetedregionsbetweenthetwomethods.WecouldrecoveraslightlylargerproportionoftheprobetargetedregionsfromtheSureSelectlibrariesandaslightlylargerproportionofthenon-repeatedpartofthetargetedregionfromtheNimblegenlibraries.ThiswassurprisingsinceAgilentusedRepeatMaskertoexcluderepeatsfromtheSureSelectdesignandwealsousedRepeatMaskertodefinetherepeatswhenweanalyzedthenon-repeatedportionofourtargetregion.Itislikelythattheregions,whichareincludedintheNimblegendesign,butexcludedfromtheSureSelectdesign,aremoredifficulttocapture.Itwouldbeinterestingtocomparethetwomethodsemployingthesamerepeatmaskingstrategyforbothtoseehowthatwouldinfluencetheresults.ItispossibletosubmitanalreadyRepeatMaskedregiontoNimblegenforadesignandacustomrepeatmaskingoptioniscurrentlyavailablewhenorderingSureSelectcaptureprobes,butitisdependentonextrabioinformaticsworkbythecustomer.Bettercoverageofthewholetargetregionwillbeincreasinglyimportantasthesequencingreadlengthgetslongerandreadscanbealignedtomorerepeatedregions.
WecalledmoreknownandnovelSNPsfromtheNimblegenlibrariesthanfromtheSureSelectlibrariesineachsample,whichisexpectedsincewealsosequencedalargerproportionofthetargetregionfromthoselibraries.WeobservedslightlybetterconcordancebetweenourSNPcallsandtheHapMapgenotypesfromtheSureSelectlibraries,whichisprobablyduetothelargerpercentageofreadsmappingtothetargetedregionandthetargetedregionbeingsmallerintheSureSelectlibraries.ThesetwofactorscombinedleadtohigheraveragecoverageintheSureSelectlibrariesdespitethedownsamplingofthenumberof
sequencereadsintheSureSelectlibrariestoequalthoseintheNimblegenlibrariesinthebeginningoftheanalysis.OurSNPcallsfrombothtypesofsequencinglibrariescorrelatedverywellwiththeHapMapgenotypesontheindividuallevelreflectingthehighqualityoftheSNPcalls.Tenoutofthe11discrepantcallsthatwereinvestigatedbySangersequencingfurtheragreedwithoursequencedata.OurSNPcallsalsocorrelatedverywellwiththedatainEnsemblvariationaswellaswiththeSNPcallsfromthe1000genomesproject.InadditiontobeinggenotypedbytheHapMapproject,theparentsofthetriothatwesequencedherearepartofthe1000genomespilotonecohortof180unrelatedindividualsthathavebeensequencedtolowcoverage.ThisexplainswhywefindsofewnovelSNPsinoursamples.Nevertheless,wedofindsomenewSNPshighlightingtheimportanceofhighcoveragesequencingtodetectallthevariationinaparticularregion.
Particularlywhenalargenumberofsamplesaretobesequenced,practicalconsiderationsareimportantinthechoiceofthesequenceenrichmentmethod.TheSureSelecthybridcaptureprotocolisfasterandeasiertoperformthantheNimblegenprotocol,whichisageneraldifferencebetweenarrayandsolutionbasedcapturemethodsratherthanbetweenthesetwomethodsinparticular.Anotheradvantageofliquid-basedcapturemethodsisthattheyareeasiertomultiplexandautomatethanarraybasedones.Multiplexingandautomationwillbecomemoreimportantinthefuture,especiallywhentargetedsequencingisbeingusedinsteadofgenotypinginstudiesinvolvingalargenumberofsamples.SolutionbasedcapturemethodsalsorequiresmalleramountsofinputDNA,whichisespeciallyimportantwhenclinicalsamplesarestudied.
Takentogether,ourresultsshowthatthestrengthsoftheSureSelectmethodarebetterspecificityandreproducibility,andthestrengthoftheNimblegenmethodisbetteroverallcoverageoftheoriginaltargetregion,whichalsoresultsinalargernumberofSNPcallspersample.ThusNimblegen’smethodperformedbetterindiscoveringvariantsinourtargetregion.Weconcludethatrepeatmaskingandprobedesignareimportantparameterswhenonewantstocaptureallthevariationinagivenregion.Combiningthestrengthsofbothmethodsshouldbeusefulinthefurtherdevelopmentofsequencecapturemethodsformassivelyparallelsequencinginthefuture.
SupportingInformation
TableS1PrimersequencesforSangersequencing.
(DOC)
TableS2NovelSNPs.
(XLS)
Acknowledgments
SequencingwasperformedusingtheGAIIXequipmentattheSNP&SEQTechnologyPlatforminUppsala.WethankMarieLinderssonandKristinaLarssonforassistancewithsequencingandJessicaNordlundforreviewingthelanguageofthemanuscript.
AuthorContributions
Conceivedanddesignedtheexperiments:AKA-CS.Performedtheexperiments:AKAA.Analyzedthedata:OKAKKL-T.Contributedreagents/materials/analysistools:SS.Wrotethepaper:AKOKAASSKL-TA-CS.
Oracle Performance Tuning 02_Using AWR and AWR-Based Tools_IT/计算机_专业... define target_wait_class = ''; define target_service_hash = ''; ...
methods for measuring the levels of protein ... an antibody for a specific protein target is ...significantly affecting the performance of the assay...
performance liquid chromatography Hongbin Guo a , ... and, however, few methods have been published ...and enrichment of target analytes from sample ...
and I-V performance_计算机软件及应用_IT/计算机_...methods like stochastic approaches [10] to predict...Thus, none of these Thevenin-based models can ...
high performance liquid chromatography; GC-MS, ... into confirmatory methods and screening methods. ...containing target analytes are added to the ...
Y-chart based system level performance analysis ...provides methods, tools, and libraries for the ...The Y-chart approach permits multiple target ...
Methods for Visual Search_专业资料。search ...results based on visual cues and associated ... MAP is a search performance metric used in ...
and co-authors using high-performance liquid ...methods.18 – 21 In this paper, we describe ...(pulse duration 2 ms) as target gas and r.f...
target and acquirer despite the importance of ...and mean returns 24 Three methods of estimating ...based return measures – Operating performance / ...
To our excitement, our parade performance was a great success. After the parade, the games started. My classmates attended various events such as running...
热门文档