文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 自然科学 > Performance_of_microarray_and_liquid_based_capture_methods_for_target_enrichment_for_massively_paral
侵权投诉

Performance_of_microarray_and_liquid_based_capture_methods_for_target_enrichment_for_massively_paral

关于芯片测序方面方法

TargetEnrichmentMethodComparison

Table1.Sequencingandalignmentstatistics.

Sample

NA10860SureSelect(Downsampled)NA10860NimblegenNA11992SureSelect(Downsampled)NA11992NimblegenNA11993SureSelect(Downsampled)NA11993Nimblegen

Numberofreads(PF)183258901009399818785249126346431914834413444317

%ofreadsthataligntogenome898590838988

Numberofreadsthataligntotarget13803067(7603844)5363593

13818498(9293047)5209663

14200810(9972236)8985107

%ofreadsthataligntotarget75(75)5374(74)4174(74)67

PF=passfilter.

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0016486.t001

readswerere-alignedagainstthehumangenomereferenceusingBWA[38].BWAplacesthereadsthataligntomultiplelocationsrandomlytooneofthoselocations.WhenthereadsmappingtothetargetregionwereextractedfromthealignmentusingSamtools[39],thereadsthatmappedtomultiplelocations,buthadbeenrandomlyplacedtoourtargetregionbyBWA,wereincluded.Between41and75%ofthequalityfilteredreadsalignedtothetargetregionspersample(Table1).Ineachsample,alargerproportionofthereadsfromthelibrariespreparedwiththeSureSelectmethod(74–75%)thanfromtheonespreparedwiththeNimblegenmethod(41–67%)alignedtothetargetregions(Table1).ThepercentageofreadsthatalignedtothetargetregionwasmoreconsistentbetweentheSureSelectlibraries.ThusthelibrariespreparedwiththeSureSelectmethodshowedhigherspecificityandbetterreproducibilitythanthelibrariespreparedwiththeNimblegenmethod.

ToavoidbiasduetothehighernumberofsequencereadsobtainedfromtheSureSelectlibrariesinthesubsequentanalysis,wedownsampledthereadsintheSureSelectlibrariestomatchthenumberofreadsobtainedfromtheNimblegenlibrariesforeachindividualandrepeatedthealignments(Table1).Wethendeterminedthecompletenessofcoverageofthetargetregioninthedifferentlibraries(Fig.1).Onaverage,wecovered99.7%oftheregionstargetedbytheSureSelectprobes(Table2)atleastonce,whichmeansthat1.7Mb(55%)oftheoriginaltargetregionwascoveredatleastoncebythe35bpsequencereads.OftheregionstargetedbytheNimblegenprobeswewereabletosequence98.5%atleastonce.Thuswewereabletosequence2.3Mb(76%)oftheoriginaltargetregionatleastonceinthelibrariespreparedwiththeNimblegenmethod.Theproportionofthetargetregionthatwassuccessfullysequencedatleastoncerepresentstheproportionofthetargetregionthatwewereabletocapturei.e.thecompletenessofthelibrary.OurresultsdemonstratethatweobtainhighercompletenessforSureSelectlibrarieswhenweconsidertheregionstargetedbythemethodspecificprobes.Nimblegenperformsalmostequallywellwhentheregionstargetedbybothprobesetsareconsideredandcovers0.6Mbmoreoftheoriginaltargetregion.Wealsolookedatthecompletenessofcoverageofthenon-repeatedpartsofthetargetregion,asthesemakeupthebiologicallymostrelevanttarget.Nimblegenperformedslightlybetterintheseregions.98.1%ofthenon-repeatedpartofthetargetwascoveredatleastonceinthelibrariespreparedwiththeNimblegenmethodcomparedto97.4%inthelibrariespreparedwiththeSureSelectmethod,onaverage(datanotshown).Howevertheresultsthatweobtained

whenlookingatthenon-repeatedpartofthetargetregionwereverysimilartotheregiontargetedbybothprobesetssotheyarenotreportedseparatelyinthefurtheranalyses.AnexampleofthecoverageofoneofthetargetgenesaswellasthepositionsoftheprobesandtherepeatelementsinbothtypesoflibrariesisshowninFigure2.

Weobtainedaveragesequencedepthsof59to101fortheNimblegenlibrariesand86to113fortheSureSelectlibrariesafterdownsampling(Table2).Toassesstheuniformityoftherepresentationofthetargetedregionsinthesequencinglibrariesinasequencingdepthindependentway,weplottedthenormalizedcoverageforeachsample[36](Fig.3).WenotethatintheSureSelectlibraries67–69%ofthetargetedbaseshadatleasthalfoftheaveragecoverage,whereasintheNimblegenlibrariesthisnumberwas61–72%.Thus,onaveragebothmethodsperformedequallywellwhenjudgedbytheuniformityofthecoverage.

SNPcallingandcomparisontoHapMappositions

IntheNimblegendesign,94–96%ofthegenotypedSNPpositionsfromHapMapforeachofthethreeindividualsamplesfellintotheprobetargetedregions,whereas69–75%oftheHapMapSNPpositionsineachindividualsamplewereintheprobetargetedregionsintheAgilentdesign.68–74%oftheHapMapSNPpositionswereintheregiontargetedbybothmethods(Table3).Intotal,wecalledbetween2405and3371SNPspersamplerequiringaminimumcoverageoften(Table4).ForeachDNAsample,thenumberofSNPscalledwashigherinthelibrarythatwaspreparedusingtheNimblegenmethodthanintheonepreparedwiththeSureSelectmethod.Intheregiontargetedbybothmethods,wecalledslightlymoreSNPsinthelibrariesthatwerepreparedwiththeSureSelectmethodonaverage.TocomparethebasecallsinoursequencingdatatothegenotypesfromHapMapforthethreesamplesthatwesequenced,wemadealistofSNPcallsobtainedusingMaqandofbasecallsatallthepositionsthathadbeengenotypedinHapMapandhadaminimumof10Xsequencingcoverageinourdataforeachsample.SinceMaqdidnotcallSNPsinthelatterpositions,weassumedthattheywereequaltothereferencesequence.WethencomparedoursequencingbasedgenotypelisttotheHapMapgenotypesforeachofthesamples(Table3).Wewereabletocall73–79%oftheHapMapSNPsinthewholetargetregionintheSureSelectlibrariesand85–96%intheNimblegenlibraries.Wecorrectlycalled93–97%oftheHapMapSNPsintheregionstargetedbybothmethodsintheSureSelectlibrariesand85–94%

上一页第4页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email