延迟命名作业中的语义干扰效应
JournalofExperimentalPsychology:Learning,Memory,andCognition2008,Vol.34,No.1,249–256
Copyright2008bytheAmericanPsychologicalAssociation0278-7393/08/$12.00DOI:10.1037/0278-7393.34.1.249
SemanticInterferenceinaDelayedNamingTask:Evidenceforthe
ResponseExclusionHypothesis
HarvardUniversityandCNRS&Universite´deProvence
NielsJanssen
UniversityofGroningen
WalterSchirm
BradfordZ.MahonandAlfonsoCaramazza
HarvardUniversityandUniversityofTrento
In2experimentsparticipantsnamedpicturesofcommonobjectswithsuperimposeddistractorwords.In
onenamingcondition,thepicturesandwordswerepresentedsimultaneouslyoneverytrial,andparticipantsproducedthetargetresponseimmediately.Intheothernamingcondition,thepresentationofthepictureprecededthepresentationofthedistractorby1,000ms,andparticipantsdelayedproductionoftheirnamingresponseuntildistractorwordpresentation.Withineachnamingcondition,thedistractorwordswereeithersemanticcategorycoordinatesofthetargetpicturesorunrelated.Orthogonaltothismanipulationofsemanticrelatedness,thefrequencyofthepictures’nameswasmanipulated.Theauthorsobservedsemanticinterferenceeffectsinboththeimmediateanddelayednamingconditionsbutafrequencyeffectonlyintheimmediatenamingcondition.Thesedataindicatethatsemanticinterferencecanbeobservedwhentargetpicturenaminglatenciesdonotreflectthebottleneckattheleveloflexicalselection.Inthecontextofotherfindingsfromthepicture–wordinterferenceparadigm,theauthorsinterpretthesedataassupportingtheviewthatthesemanticinterferenceeffectarisesatapostlexicallevelofprocessing.
Keywords:semanticinterferenceeffect,lexicalselectionbycompetition,picture–wordinterference,delayednaming,responseexclusionhypothesis
Acentralquestioninlanguageproductionresearchconcernsthedynamicalprinciplesthatgovernthemechanismresponsibleforretrievingwordsfromthementallexicon.Awidespreadassump-tioninlanguageproductionmodelsisthatlexicalselectionisacompetitiveprocess(e.g.,LaHeij,1988;Levelt,Roelofs,&Meyer,1999;Roelofs,2003).Thehypothesisoflexicalselectionbycompetitionproposesthatthetimeittakestoselectatargetwordincreasesasthelevelsofactivationofnontargetwordsincrease.Theprimarysourceofempiricalevidencecitedinsup-portoflexicalselectionbycompetitionisthesemanticinterfer-
NielsJanssen,DepartmentofPsychology,HarvardUniversity,andLaboratoiredePsychologieCognitive,CNRS&Universite´deProvence,Marseille,France;WalterSchirm,DepartmentofPsychology,UniversityofGroningen,Groningen,theNetherlands;BradfordZ.MahonandAl-fonsoCaramazza,DepartmentofPsychology,HarvardUniversity,andCentreforMind/BrainSciences,UniversityofTrento,Trento,Italy.
ThisresearchwassupportedbyNationalInstituteofHealthGrantDC04542toAlfonsoCaramazzaandbyapostdoctoralfellowshipfromtheFyssenFoundationtoNielsJanssen.WalterSchirmreceivedsupportfromtheDutchBrainFoundation,theDutchAphasiaFoundation,andtheDr.HendrikMullerFoundation.BradfordZ.MahonwassupportedbyaNationalScienceFoundationGraduateResearchFellowship.WewouldliketothankYanchaoBi,XavierAlario,andJorgeAlmeidaforhelpfulcomments.
CorrespondenceconcerningthisarticleshouldbeaddressedtoNielsJanssen,LaboratoiredePsychologieCognitive,CNRS&Universite´deProvence,3placeVictorHugo–Case66,13331MarseilleCedex3,France.E-mail:janssen@up.univ-mrs.fr
249
enceeffect(e.g.,Lupker,1979;Rosinski,1977):Namingapictureofanobject(e.g.,CAR)isslowerinthecontextofasemanticcategorycoordinatedistractorword(e.g.,truck)comparedtoanunrelateddistractorword(e.g.,table).Theexplanationofthesemanticinterferenceeffectintermsoflexicalselectionbycom-petitionassumesthatsemanticcategorycoordinatedistractorsleadtomorehighlyactivatedlexicalrepresentationsthandounrelateddistractors.1
Recently,theassumptionthatlexicalselectionisacompetitiveprocesshasbeenchallenged.Anumberofstudieshaveobservedsemanticfacilitationeffectswhentargetpicturesanddistractorwordsaresemanticallyrelated.Forexample,namingapictureofanobject(e.g.,CAR)is(a)fasterinthecontextofasemanticallyrelatedverbdistractor(e.g.,drive)comparedtoanunrelatedverbdistractor(e.g.,read;Mahon,Costa,Peterson,Vargas,&Car-amazza,2007),(b)fasterinthecontextofadistractorwordthatreferstoapartofthetargetobject(e.g.,engine)comparedtoanunrelateddistractor(e.g.,branches;Costa,Alario,&Caramazza,2005),(c)fasterinthecontextofawithin-categorysemanticallyclosedistractorword(e.g.,truck)comparedtoawithin-categorysemanticallyfardistractorword(e.g.,wagon;Mahonetal.,2007;butseeVigliocco,Vinson,Lewis,&Garrett,2004),and(d)fasterinthecontextofamaskedsemanticcategorycoordinatedistractor
Thisisbecauselexicalrepresentationsofsemanticcategorycoordinatedistractorsreceiveactivationfromtwosources(thepictureandword),whereasthoseofunrelateddistractorsreceiveactivationfromonlyonesource(theword).
1
28页 5财富值 Troldborg et al. 2008-JC... 暂无评价 15页 免费 crop science wang et al ... 11页 5财富值 2008_Janssen_et_al 8页 免费...
Taminiau-et-al.-2008-N... 暂无评价 4页 免费 Wang et al. 1 10页 ...Janssen Research Foundation, Turnhoutseweg, 30, B-2340 Beerse, Belgium § ...
28页 5财富值 Troldborg et al. 2008-JC... 暂无评价 15页 免费 crop science wang et al ... 11页 5财富值 2008_Janssen_et_al 8页 免费...
28页 5财富值 Troldborg et al. 2008-JC... 暂无评价 15页 免费 crop science wang et al ... 11页 5财富值 2008_Janssen_et_al 8页 免费喜欢此文档...
2008-Kuiper Chemosphere_教育学/心理学_人文社科_专业资料。Chemosphere 73 (...levels after exposure to contaminated harbor sludge (Janssen et al., 1997)...
JAMA, [13] Lee SJ, Janssen I, Heymsfield SB, et al Relation between ...J Clin Endocrinol Metab, 2008, 93 )(1 :139-146. [17] Sattler FR,...
(Hagedoorn, Van Yperen, Van de Vliert, et al., 1999), 基于动机(Van ...Janssen, Vries & Cozijnsen, 1998) 、个人控制 (Tangirala & Ramanujam, 2008...
812 XIAN-JANSSEN 4,652,302 NOVARTIS 3,452,377 PFIZER 5,628,086 LILLY ...50 –60 –70 - 35% - 64% P=0.012 P=0.0061 Hanefeld M, et al....
( Janssen et al. , 1995; 王世 梅和周立祥, 2005) 加入到溶有 11 12g...6g 铁 , 沉淀率为 36 7% , 这与廖岳华 ( 2008) 报道的生物 . 合成施...
释” Colman, 2006 年至今, 2006; Henrich et al. , 2006; 大量研究围绕 化解二阶社会困境展开( Gürerk et al. , Gintis, 2008; Janssen and Bushman, ...
热门文档