COGNITIVE CONSEQUENCES OF FORCED COMPLIANCE
Leon Festinger & James M. Carlsmith[] (1959)
First published in Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 58, 203-210.
What happens to a person's private opinion if he is forced to do or say something contrary to that opinion? Only recently has there been any experimental work related to this question. Two studies reported by Janis and King (1954; 1956) clearly showed that, at least under some conditions, the private opinion changes so as to bring it into closer correspondence with the overt behavior the person was forced to perform. Specifically, they showed that if a person is forced to improvise a speech supporting a point of view with which he disagrees, his private opinion moves toward the position advocated in the speech. The observed opinion change is greater than for persons who only hear the speech or for persons who read a prepared speech with emphasis solely on execution and manner of delivery The authors of these two studies explain their results mainly in terms of mental rehearsal and thinking up new arguments. In this way, they propose, the person who is forced to improvise a speech convinces himself. They present some evidence, which is not altogether conclusive, in support of this explanation. We will have more to say concerning this explanation in discussing the results of our experiment.
Kelman (1953) tried to pursue the matter further. He reasoned that if the person is induced to make an overt statement contrary to his private opinion by the offer of some reward,
then the greater the reward offered, the greater should be the subsequent opinion change. His data, however did not support this idea. He found, rather, that a large reward produced less subsequent opinion change than did a smaller reward. Actually this finding by Kelman is consistent with the theory we will outline below but, for a number of reasons is not conclusive. One of the major weaknesses of the data is that not all subjects in the experiment made an overt statement contrary to their private opinion in order to obtain the offered reward. What is more, as one might expect, the percentage of subjects who complied increased as the size of the offered reward increased. Thus, with self-selection of who did and who did not make the required overt statement and with varying percentages of subjects in the different conditions who did make the requsted statement, no interpretation of the data can be unequivocal. Recently Festinger (1957) proposed a theory concerning cognitive dissonance from which come a number of derivations about opinion change following forced compliance. Since these derivations are stated in detail by Festinger (1957, Ch. 4), we will here give only a brief outline of the reasoning.
Let us consider a person who privately holds opinion "X" but has, as a result of pressure brought to bear on him publicly stated that he believes "not X."
1. This person has two cognitions which, psychologically, do not fit together: one of these is the knowledge that he believes "X," the other the knowledge that he has publicly stated that he believes "not X." If no factors other than his private opinion are considered it would follow, at least in our culture, that if he believes "X" he would publicly state "X." Hence, his cognition
(1959). Cognitive consequences of forced compliance. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 58, 203-10. 十大杰出社会心理学研究(三)——Robbers Cave实验中的战争与...
COGNITIVE CONSEQUENCES OF FORCED COMPLIANCE --LEON FESTINGER AND JAMES M. CARLSMITH1 申艳娥 COPYRIGHT interview 费斯廷格 leon festinger 申艳娥 COPYRIGHT ...
Carlsmith. Cognitive Consequences of Forced Compliance. 吴志明 All copyrights reserved The Theory of Cognitive Dissonance ? Cognitive Dissonance – Any ...
参考书目 Festinger, L., & Carlsmith, J. (1959). Cognitive consequences of forced compliance. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 58, 203-10. ...
The Consequences of assu... 暂无评价 5页 免费 Forced exposure and psyc.... A Cognitive Model of the Antecedents and Consequences of Satisfaction ...
cognitive impairment, and permanent tracheostomies ...compliance, especially if the recipe is readily ...Degradation of glycopyrrolate was forced by treating...
a cognitive model of the... 10页 免费 ... Forced exposure and psyc... 暂无评价 13页 ... Antecedents and consequences of organisational ...
The Consequences of assu... 暂无评价 5页 免费 Forced exposure and psyc.... Oliver, Richard L., A Cognitive Model of the Antecedents and Consequences...
forced-compliance paradigm (Aronson, Cohen, & ...cognitive activation of close positive relationships ...Moreover, our research isolates the consequences ...
Forced exposure and psyc... 暂无评价 13页 ...and Consequences of Perceived Capacities in the ...更多>>Bandura’s social cognitive construct “...
热门文档